Why Humanity Will Never Leave The Solar System

Kurzgesagt – In a Nutshell12:432026-08-04English

This Kurzgesagt video points out that even if a spacecraft could reach 20% of the speed of light, vast distances, high-speed collisions, and the lack of any clearly habitable destinations nearby could still make crewed interstellar travel hard to achieve.

Overview

Why Humanity Will Never Leave The Solar System

Key points

  • At the Parker Solar Probe's speed of 635,000 kilometers per hour, it would take only about two weeks to reach Mars and about a year to reach Pluto, but about 2,500 years to reach the outer edge of the Oort Cloud.
  • The video treats nuclear fusion and antimatter propulsion as physically possible concepts with engineering problems that have yet to be solved. If a spacecraft could reach 20% of the speed of light, it would take about 8 years to reach the outer edge of the Oort Cloud and about 20 years to reach Alpha Centauri.
  • At 20% of the speed of light, a single dust grain hitting the spacecraft would erode its shield like a small explosion. The video estimates that hitting a golf-ball-sized rock would release more than twice as much energy as the atomic bomb dropped on Hiroshima.
  • If a crewed journey is limited to 40 years, even traveling at 20% of the speed of light would only extend its range to about 8 light-years. Nearby planets in the habitable zone still might not actually be suitable for human survival.
  • More promising destinations could be tens or even thousands of light-years away. Even if we could one day slow aging, carry embryos on AI-controlled spacecraft, and use more advanced telescopes to screen potential destinations, it's still hard to imagine maintaining an interconnected interstellar civilization.
  • The video doesn't treat its title as a settled conclusion: The New York Times once predicted that powered flight was still 1 million to 10 million years away, but according to the video, the first successful flight took place just 69 days later.

Chapter notes

The invisible barrier of distance

  • Humans may never be able to leave the solar system, and other civilizations may have just as much trouble venturing into deep space. The first invisible barrier is distance: it's hard to intuitively tell the difference between “very far” and “a million times farther than very far.”
  • In 1969, astronauts returning from the Moon reached 40,000 kilometers per hour. The speed record for a human-made object was set by the Parker Solar Probe, which used Venus's gravity to speed up and reached 635,000 kilometers per hour after seven years. That's fast enough to circle Earth in 4 minutes and cover the distance from Earth to the Moon in 36 minutes.
  • If a crewed spacecraft could match the Parker Solar Probe's speed, it would take only two weeks to reach Mars, compared with 7 to 10 months using current rockets. It would take about a year to reach Pluto, another two years to cross the heliopause, and one more year to overtake Voyager 2, which has been traveling for more than 50 years. But it would still take 2,500 years to reach the outer edge of the Oort Cloud, which is considered the true boundary of the solar system.
  • Some 2,500 years is roughly the time from the founding of the Roman Republic to today, and once you got there, there would still be nothing but empty space ahead. We don't know how to travel faster than light, teleport, or freeze the crew. By contrast, using nuclear fusion or antimatter propulsion to reach a fraction of the speed of light is physically possible.
  • Setting engineering challenges aside for now, if we optimistically assume a spacecraft could reach 20% of the speed of light—60,000 kilometers per second, or 216 million kilometers per hour—it would take just 3.5 days to reach the edge of the solar system, 8 years to reach the outer edge of the Oort Cloud, and 20 years to reach Alpha Centauri, the nearest star system.

High-speed collisions and nearby stars

  • Interstellar space is sparse, but it still contains high-energy particles, gas, and dust. At 20% of the speed of light, a single iron atom can leave a trail of damage several tenths of a millimeter deep in the hull. Over time, the hull would become riddled with microscopic holes.
  • A shield can absorb most molecules that hit it, or at least slow them down, but a dust grain hitting the spacecraft at 20% of the speed of light would vaporize explosively like a hand grenade, gradually wearing down the shield. Hitting a golf-ball-sized rock would release more than twice the energy of the atomic bomb dropped on Hiroshima. Collision damage increases rapidly with speed, so 20% of the speed of light may already be close to the practical speed limit.
  • Assuming the shield is strong enough, a spacecraft might be able to reach nearby stars at about 20% of the speed of light. A more realistic, slower spacecraft would take about 10,000 years to reach Alpha Centauri, while the fictional high-speed spacecraft would take just 20 years. In this scenario, the message the crew sends after arriving takes another 4 years to reach Earth: the planets there are spectacular and of great astrophysical interest, but they're extremely dangerous and uninhabitable.
  • If 20% of the speed of light is the limit, keeping the journey under 40 years would mean reaching no farther than 8 light-years. The destinations within that range have scientific value, but there may not be a single one worth spending decades in a cramped spacecraft traveling through an extremely dangerous environment to reach.
  • The solar system sits in a relatively empty part of the Milky Way. Our stellar neighborhood, about 25 light-years across, accounts for just 0.02% of the galaxy and currently contains 34 stars and 6 brown dwarfs. Only 3 of the stars are like the Sun, and one of them is the Sun itself. Another is Alpha Centauri A.
  • Most of the other nearby stars are red dwarfs, and their planets are generally very dangerous. Being in the habitable zone only means liquid water could exist there; it doesn't guarantee that a planet is habitable. Mars is also in the Sun's habitable zone, and even GJ 1061 d, one of the most Earth-like-looking candidate planets, might turn out to be a Mars-like world for someone who spends a lifetime getting there.

Distant destinations and what technology might change

  • Some stars may have truly habitable planets, with oceans, a breathable atmosphere, or perhaps even life, at least in the form of microbes, making them worth investigating. But they may be tens or even thousands of light-years away, and even at a substantial fraction of the speed of light, the trip could still take hundreds or even thousands of years.
  • Future humans with more advanced technology and a stronger desire to explore might find a way to deal with biological aging and make journeys lasting centuries acceptable. They might also send embryos on AI-controlled spacecraft and use more advanced telescopes to avoid deadly, empty star systems. But without technology straight out of science fiction, it's still hard to imagine how an interconnected civilization could be built and maintained.
  • Deep-space exploration is limited by both immense distances and a speed limit. Even if those obstacles were overcome, almost every destination just barely within reach might not be worth visiting. Current rockets, computers, and even nuclear fusion reactors fall far short. The breakthroughs we'd need would have to be as hard for people today to imagine as a Moon landing would have been for hunter-gatherers.
  • Whether such breakthroughs will happen is still unknown, but predictions about technology are easy to get wrong. In 1903, The New York Times editorial “Flying Machines Which Do Not Fly” declared that it would take humanity 1 million to 10 million years to achieve powered flight. Just 69 days later, the first successful flight took place, and 66 years later, humans landed on the Moon.
  • The narrator hopes that in a hundred years this video will seem as absurd as that editorial. It's also possible that the whole way of thinking about it is wrong, and that the future lies not in distant space but somewhere deeper.

What it answers

If a crewed spacecraft could match the speed of today's fastest probe, how long would it take to leave the solar system?
Using the video's definition of the outer edge of the Oort Cloud as the boundary of the solar system, it would take about 2,500 years at 635,000 kilometers per hour. By comparison, it would take only about two weeks to reach Mars.
Why can't we shorten interstellar trips simply by making spacecraft faster?
The faster a spacecraft goes, the more damage a collision with an atom, a dust grain, or a rock can cause. Shields can reduce the damage from some small particles, but dust erodes them, and larger rocks can cause extremely severe impacts.
Is the nearest star system to the Sun worth sending people to?
The video sees Alpha Centauri as scientifically valuable, but uses a fictional report from the crew on arrival to make a point: spending 20 years getting there doesn't mean you'll find a planet you can survive on.
Does being in the habitable zone mean humans can live on a planet?
No. The video says that being in the habitable zone only means liquid water could exist there, and points to Mars, which is also in the Sun's habitable zone, as a counterexample.
Does the video really conclude that humanity will never leave the solar system?
No. The narrator thinks current technology falls far short but explicitly says we don't know what the future holds, citing how badly progress on powered flight was underestimated.

Quotes

Very far and a million times very far feels the same, but it's not.
Unfortunately, we'll run into a few obstacles on the way, literally, because while space is very empty, it's not actually empty.
The longer you think about deep space, the less it makes sense.

Mentioned

  • Parker Solar Probe — The video uses this probe's speed of 635,000 kilometers per hour as a benchmark for estimating travel times.
  • Voyager 2 — This probe traveled for more than 50 years to reach the point the video uses as a distance marker.
  • 奥尔特云 — The video treats its outer edge as the true boundary of the solar system to show how far you have to travel just to enter interstellar space.
  • Alpha Centauri — This is the closest star system to the Sun and the first destination of the video's hypothetical crewed interstellar mission.
  • GJ 1061 d — The video uses this relatively Earth-like-looking planet to show that surface similarities don't guarantee habitability.
  • 宜居带 — The video uses the term for the region around a star where liquid water could exist and stresses that being within it doesn't mean a planet is suitable for human survival.
  • The New York Times — The video quotes a 1903 editorial from the newspaper that badly underestimated progress on powered flight to show how hard it is to predict technological breakthroughs.