Quantum Fields: The Real Building Blocks of the Universe - with David Tong
The Royal Institution1:00:172017-02-15English
Chapters
In this lecture, theoretical physicist David Tong explains that modern physics treats quantum fields that fill space as the basic building blocks, while particles such as electrons, quarks, and photons are quantized excitations of those fields.
Overview
Quantum Fields: The Real Building Blocks of…
- Starting with the question “What are we made of?”, this chapter looks back at how electrons, atomic nuclei, and quarks gradually replaced the periodic table as a deeper description of matter.
- Magnets, an induction experiment, and light illustrate what fields mean physically. Combining fields with quantum mechanics then explains why photons, electrons, and quarks can be seen as quantized excitations of fields.
- A vacuum simulation and the Casimir force show that even empty space fluctuates, before a comparison of how difficult it is to calculate the electron’s magnetic moment and the proton’s mass.
- This chapter lists the three generations of matter fields and the four fundamental interactions, then explains how the discovery of the Higgs boson supplied the last piece of the Standard Model.
- This chapter shows the equations, including the gravity term, and what they can explain, then discusses why dark matter, dark energy, and inflation need further explanation and what clues the polarization of the microwave background might offer.
- This chapter reviews the goals of the collider upgrade, explains how similarities in the equations inspired grand unification, supersymmetry, and string theory, and shows why these ideas still need experimental tests.
- This chapter compares three options—keep waiting, build a bigger collider, or take a fresh look at the existing equations—and closes by explaining how quantum discreteness emerges from the smooth Schrödinger equation.
Key points
- Ordinary matter can be described in terms of electrons, up quarks, and down quarks, but in quantum field theory, each of these three particles is an excitation of its own underlying field. Electrons in different people’s bodies are excitations of the same electron field.
- Even after all particles are removed, quantum fields remain in the vacuum and continue to fluctuate. The lecture illustrates this with the measurable Casimir force between two metal plates.
- The precision of quantum field theory calculations depends on the problem: predictions for the electron’s magnetic moment agree with measurements to about 12 significant digits, while, according to the lecture, first-principles calculations of the proton’s mass were accurate to only about 3% at the time.
- The 12 known matter fields are divided into three generations of four. Ordinary matter mainly involves the electron and the two quarks from the first generation, but it is still unclear why there are exactly three generations.
- ATLAS and CMS discovered the Higgs boson at the Large Hadron Collider, providing direct evidence for the Higgs field. The electron’s mass, for example, reflects the interaction between the electron field and the Higgs field.
- The lecture traces temperature variations in the cosmic microwave background to early quantum fluctuations that inflation stretched and froze in place, but it is still unknown which field left the imprint.
- As of the lecture, the upgraded Large Hadron Collider had not found the expected new physics. Tong personally favors taking this as a chance to rethink the theoretical assumptions of the past 30 years or so, rather than simply waiting for more data or building a bigger machine.
Chapter notes
From the Periodic Table to Quarks
- The lecture begins with a question that goes back at least 2,500 years to ancient Greece: What basic ingredients make up us and everything else in the universe?
- The periodic table gave us the first modern picture of what matter is made of: if you break any material down into its chemical components, they can be traced to the roughly 120 elements in the table, 10 of which were discovered in this very building. In the 19th century, people regarded the elements as the most basic ingredients in nature.
- J.J. Thomson discovered a particle smaller than the atom—the electron—and announced the discovery in 1897 in the same lecture hall and the same lecture series. At least half the audience did not believe him, and one prominent scientist thought it was a joke.
- Less than 15 years after the discovery of the electron, Ernest Rutherford proposed a picture of the inside of the atom: the nucleus at the center was as tiny as a fly in the middle of a cathedral, while electrons moved around it in ill-defined orbits and sparsely occupied the rest of the space. It was later discovered that the nucleus was not fundamental either, but contained protons and neutrons.
- In the 1970s, it was discovered that protons and neutrons are each made of three quarks: a proton contains two up quarks and one down quark, while a neutron contains two down quarks and one up quark. “Up” and “down” are just names and do not refer to position or direction.
- So far, no smaller components have been found inside electrons or quarks. In this picture, all the different kinds of matter we see are simply electrons, up quarks, and down quarks arranged over and over in different ways. This carries on Democritus’s basic idea that the world can be put together from a few basic ingredients, like Lego bricks.
From Faraday’s Fields to Quantum Particles
- Treating electrons and quarks as the basic building blocks of the universe is a simplification for teaching purposes. Our best physical theories are based on fields. A field extends throughout the universe and has a value at every point in space. That value can change over time, like ripples moving through a fluid.
- The closer two repelling magnets are brought together, the more strongly you feel them push apart. Michael Faraday thought that although the space between the magnets looked empty, something real but invisible was producing the force. He called it lines of force; today we call it a magnetic field.
- In the induction demonstration, a battery sends current through a small coil, A, causing it to produce a magnetic field. When A passes through a larger coil, B, the moving magnetic field induces a current in B, making a needle at the other end of the table deflect. This shows that fields can affect objects at a distance without direct contact.
- In the last 20 minutes of an 1846 lecture, Michael Faraday proposed that light is made of ripples in electric and magnetic fields. About 50 years later, Maxwell, Hertz, and others confirmed the idea.
- Quantum mechanics says that energy is not continuous but comes in packets. Quantum field theory combines this idea with fields that ripple continuously. Once quantized, a seemingly smooth electromagnetic wave shows up as individual photons.
- Similarly, electrons are discrete excitations of the electron field that fills the universe, and the electrons in different people’s bodies all come from the same field. Up and down quarks come from two different quark fields, respectively. The same principle applies to other particles.
Vacuum Fluctuations and the Limits of Calculation
- After all the atoms and other particles are removed from a box, the fields are still there. Computer simulations based on the Standard Model show that even in a pure vacuum, the fields cannot remain still: they must still obey Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle.
- Fields keep fluctuating in a pure vacuum. These are quantum vacuum fluctuations. Their effects can be measured through the Casimir force: there are more fluctuations outside two metal plates than between them, so the plates are pushed toward each other. Measurements agree with the theoretical prediction.
- If even the simplest vacuum is this complicated, describing one particle is harder still, let alone describing what 10²³ particles do together. Simulating the fluctuations on a computer does not count as solving the problem. Explaining the patterns that appear in the fluctuations by solving the equations from first principles is one of six unsolved million-dollar math problems.
- When vacuum fluctuations are fairly mild, quantum field theory can make extremely precise predictions. For the electron’s magnetic moment, for example, the results of decades of precision experiments agree with first-principles theoretical calculations to about 12 to 13 significant digits.
- The stronger the fluctuations, the harder the calculation. Take the proton’s mass: the equations are already known, but after about 40 years of research, even with the world’s most powerful computers, the calculation is accurate to only about 3%.
- In some cases, even computers cannot help, and researchers do not yet know where to begin. Quantum field theory is both our most successful physical theory and the one we understand least well. To make progress, we need both a deeper understanding of the theory and a clearer idea of how to apply it to experiments.
Matter Fields, Fundamental Forces, and the Higgs Field
- Ordinary matter is made of electrons, up quarks, and down quarks, but what is truly fundamental are the fields behind those particles. The fourth particle in the first generation is the neutrino. Neutrinos rarely interact with matter. Since the lecture began, about 10¹⁴ have passed through each person in the audience, some of them after passing through Earth itself.
- The second generation includes the muon, a neutrino, the strange quark, and the charm quark. The third includes the tau, a neutrino, the bottom quark, and the top quark. Altogether, the three generations contain 12 matter fields. Muons and taus behave like electrons, but are about 200 and 3,000 times as massive, respectively. There is an explanation for why each generation has four members, but why there are exactly three generations remains a mystery.
- The four fundamental interactions are gravity, electromagnetism, the strong nuclear force, and the weak nuclear force. The field associated with gravity is spacetime itself, and electromagnetism is associated with the electromagnetic field. The strong nuclear force binds quarks inside protons and neutrons through the gluon field. The weak nuclear force is associated with the W and Z boson fields and plays a role in radioactive decay and in making the Sun shine.
- The 12 matter fields and four force fields are not independent; they can excite one another. For example, oscillations in the electron field can set the electromagnetic field oscillating and produce light, which can then interact with quark fields and set them oscillating.
- Peter Higgs proposed the Higgs field in the 1960s. By the 1970s it was an important part of the theory, but getting direct evidence meant making the field ripple and producing the corresponding boson. The ATLAS and CMS experiments at the LHC observed a small peak in their data, confirming the existence of the Higgs boson. Its lifetime is only about 10⁻²² seconds.
- An electron’s electric charge reflects the interaction between the electron field and the electromagnetic field, while its mass reflects the interaction between the electron field and the Higgs field. About 50 years after it was predicted, the Higgs boson was finally produced at CERN. It behaved as the theory predicted, supplying the last piece of the Standard Model.
What the Equations Explain and What Cosmology Still Can’t
- The equations on display begin with the gravity term written down by Albert Einstein. Solving that term lets us predict how fast an apple falls, the elliptical orbits of planets, the gravitational waves emitted when black holes merge, and how the universe as a whole expands.
- The equations also cover the electromagnetic interaction described by James Clerk Maxwell, the strong and weak nuclear forces, Peter Higgs’s equation, and the interaction between matter and the Higgs particle. All 12 particles that make up matter obey the same equation, written by Paul Dirac. This set of equations can explain every experiment conducted so far, but not all astronomical observations.
- Dark matter is invisible and more abundant than visible matter. Its presence can be inferred from the way galaxies rotate and light bends around them. Dark energy is described as an unknown field that fills space and causes things in the universe to repel one another. The rapid expansion that occurred less than a second after the Big Bang is called inflation, and it is another phenomenon the current equations cannot explain.
- The universe is about 13.8 billion years old. It is still unclear how it got started, but for the first 380,000 years after its birth, it was filled with a gradually cooling fireball. The cosmic microwave background we observe today is the light left over from that fireball. The red and blue areas in the image are warmer and cooler, respectively, and the temperature variations carry information about the early universe.
- About 10⁻³⁰ seconds after the Big Bang, there were no particles yet, but there were already quantum fields everywhere, along with their vacuum fluctuations. Inflation stretched these microscopic fluctuations to scales spanning roughly 20 billion light-years and froze them in place. The resulting patterns agree with observations of the microwave background.
- We still do not know which field left its imprint on the microwave background. The only possible candidate in the Standard Model is the Higgs field, but most researchers think a new field is more likely. Measuring the polarization of the microwave background light more precisely could help determine the properties of that field and is an important way to explore physics beyond the Standard Model.
The Collider and the Search for a Unified Theory
- The LHC discovered the Higgs boson in 2012, then shut down for two years for an upgrade. It restarted in 2015 at twice the energy it had when it discovered the Higgs boson. The upgrade had two goals: to study the Higgs boson in more detail, which it has done very successfully, and to look for new physics beyond the Standard Model.
- Just as repeating patterns in the periodic table hinted at a deeper structure behind the elements, theoretical physicists look for similar clues in their equations. The equations for electromagnetism and the strong and weak nuclear forces are very similar, so these three forces may simply be the same force viewed from different perspectives.
- The 12 matter fields, including neutrinos, electrons, and quarks, all obey the same Dirac equation. This suggests they might be the same field and the same particle viewed from different perspectives. The idea of combining three forces into one is called grand unification, and writing down a mathematical theory that does this is not difficult.
- Although matter and forces are described by different equations, they are all fields in the end. Supersymmetry offers a way to link the two. String theory takes the idea a step further: gravity, the other forces, particles, and the Higgs boson would all emerge from a single basic concept.
- These ideas drove theoretical physics for about 30 years, but experiments still have to determine whether they are right. There is currently no available way to test string theory. Testing other ideas of this kind and exploring physics beyond the Standard Model was another reason the LHC was built, alongside the search for the Higgs boson.
What to Do When There Are No New Discoveries
- The LHC (Large Hadron Collider) had been running for two years, and the equipment had performed almost perfectly, but none of the new phenomena predicted by those theories had appeared. Physicists did not agree on what to do next, and David Tong outlined three responses.
- The first option is to keep waiting. Some senior colleagues think the LHC could still make a startling discovery next year or the year after. Tong acknowledges they could be right, but they had also expected a discovery by now. If the next two years or so turn up nothing, he thinks the chances of finding anything after that are slim.
- The second option is to build a collider ten times as big to test the existing theories, but the new machine would cost about $10 billion. Tong thinks that if it does get built, the Chinese government will pay for it. Bringing the particle physicists and engineers currently working at CERN in Geneva to a town north of Beijing could be seen as a political and economic gain. Construction would take about 20 years.
- Tong favors the third option: take a fresh look at the basic equations we know are right but are still far from fully understanding, and question the assumptions and frameworks used over the past 30 years. What look like clues to a unified theory in the equations may be misleading, and a closer look might instead reveal other patterns. In Tong’s view, the lack of new discoveries at the LHC gives everyone a chance to rethink their ideas.
- New directions might come from unexplored mathematical patterns or from connections with condensed matter physics or quantum information science. Tong remains optimistic about making progress of a different kind than originally expected. He calls the existing equations the greatest equations humans have ever written, but hopes that one day we can write better ones.
- The Schrödinger equation itself is not discrete. It describes a smooth, field-like wave function. Discreteness emerges when you solve the equation; it is not written into the fundamental laws of nature from the outset.
What it answers
- If fields are the basic building blocks, what exactly are particles?
- Particles are quantized excitations of fields. Photons come from the electromagnetic field, and electrons come from the same electron field that fills all of space.
- What is left in a vacuum after all the particles have been removed?
- Quantum fields are still there, and they are not still. The lecture calls these variations quantum vacuum fluctuations and uses the Casimir force to illustrate their measurable effects.
- Why was the discovery of the Higgs boson so important?
- It provided direct evidence for the Higgs field and filled a long-standing gap in the Standard Model. In this framework, the masses of particles such as electrons reflect their interactions with the Higgs field.
- How does the cosmic microwave background record early quantum fluctuations?
- As the lecture explains it, inflation stretched microscopic fluctuations to cosmic scales and froze them in place, leaving the temperature variations we see today. But the field that produced the fluctuations has not been identified.
- If the collider cannot find new physics, what can we do next?
- The lecture lays out three options: keep waiting for data, build a bigger collider, or go back and dig deeper into the existing equations while challenging long-held assumptions. Tong personally favors the third option and is optimistic about new ideas from condensed matter physics and quantum information science.
Quotes
The electrons in your body are the ripples of the same field as the electrons in my body.
These are things that we call quantum vacuum fluctuations, but this is what nothingness looks like.
You're all made of quantum fields, and I don't understand them.
You know, it's when we're wrong that we start to make progress.
Mentioned
- David Tong — The theoretical physicist giving the lecture, who goes from the basic ingredients of matter to possible directions for the search for new physics.
- J.J. Thomson — The physicist who discovered the electron and announced the discovery in the same lecture hall in 1897.
- Ernest Rutherford — Proposed the picture of the atom as a tiny nucleus with electrons distributed around it.
- Michael Faraday — Developed an intuitive picture of electric and magnetic fields, discovered electromagnetic induction, and suggested that light is a wave in the electromagnetic field.
- James Clerk Maxwell — The lecture credits him with the electromagnetism term in the equations shown.
- 量子场论 — The theory that combines quantum mechanics with continuous fields and describes particles as quantized excitations of those fields.
- 标准模型 — The lecture uses it to describe the known matter fields and their interactions, and calls the Higgs boson its last piece.
- Peter Higgs — The physicist who proposed the field that would later bear his name in the 1960s.
- CERN — Located near Geneva and home to the Large Hadron Collider.
- 大型强子对撞机(LHC) — The collider that discovered the Higgs boson in 2012 and, after an upgrade, continued to study the Higgs and search for new physics beyond the Standard Model.
- 宇宙微波背景辐射 — Radiation left over from the fireball of the early universe, whose temperature variations provide clues to early quantum fluctuations.
- 暴胀 — A period of rapid expansion in the early universe that the lecture uses to explain how microscopic fluctuations were stretched to cosmic scales.