汪景琇院士:宇宙中最灿烂的星辰【中科院科学公开课S02EP01】
二次元的中科院物理所47:272022-07-20Chinese
Chapters
In this public science lecture, Wang Jingxiu uses examples such as nuclear fusion, the Sun’s magnetic field, and neutrinos to show that the Sun is not only our closest star but also a natural laboratory for testing fundamental physics and understanding Earth’s environment.
Overview
汪景琇院士:宇宙中最灿烂的星辰【中科院科学公开课S02EP01】
- Starting with the Lascaux Cave and Qu Yuan’s Heavenly Questions, the lecture moves through ancient Chinese records of solar eclipses and sunspots, then reviews how heliocentrism, the laws of planetary motion, and modern astronomical instruments changed our understanding of the solar system.
- The lecture explains the Sun’s internal structure, how nuclear fusion powers it, and how the energy moves outward, then describes how the theory of what powers stars inspired experiments in controlled thermonuclear fusion.
- Starting with measurements of sunspot magnetic fields and how magnetic fields emerge, the lecture traces how flares and coronal mass ejections lead to auroras and power grid disruptions on Earth, and also introduces small-scale solar activity.
- Alfvén waves and the solar neutrino deficit show how research on the Sun advanced magnetohydrodynamics and particle physics, leading into observations that combine neutrinos, cosmic rays, gravitational waves, and electromagnetic radiation.
- The lecture moves from the hypothesis that early solar activity may have helped organic molecules form, and from asteroid samples, to exoplanets, pointing out that assessing habitability takes more than checking for water.
- The Voyager probes and the plasma clouds around the solar system take the discussion beyond the heliosphere. The lecture closes with the opportunities offered by next-generation telescopes, solar probes, and theoretical research.
Key points
- From Sun symbols in the Lascaux Cave dating back about 16,500 years to ancient Chinese records of solar eclipses and observations of sunspots, people were studying the Sun long before modern telescopes existed.
- The Sun’s core releases energy by fusing hydrogen nuclei into helium nuclei, inspiring research on controlled nuclear fusion on Earth. The lecture describes how China’s fully superconducting tokamak sustained a controlled plasma for 1,056 seconds and can reach temperatures above 100 million degrees.
- George Hale used the Zeeman effect to measure the strong magnetic fields of sunspots. Observations of the Sun and space also advanced magnetohydrodynamics: plasma in a magnetic field can carry Alfvén waves like a string that has been disturbed.
- When the magnetic cloud formed by a coronal mass ejection reaches Earth, its interaction with the magnetosphere can produce auroras and may also disrupt power grids. The lecture cites a solar eruption in March 1989 that left the entire province of Quebec without power for nine hours.
- Davis detected only about a third of the solar neutrinos predicted by theory. Later experiments confirmed that neutrinos oscillate and have rest mass, making solar observations a clue that helped advance particle physics.
- The speaker points out that defining a habitable zone by whether a planet could have water is not enough to determine whether life could survive there over the long term. It is also important to consider whether the planet’s electromagnetic environment, including features like a magnetosphere, can shield it from the effects of the solar wind and high-energy particles.
- From probes that venture deep into the Sun’s atmosphere to space-based solar observatories that can measure magnetic fields and observe solar eruptions, new instruments make observations possible that could not be made before. The speaker emphasizes that theoretical research must keep pace.
Chapter notes
From ancient records to the revolution in astronomy
- The earliest known prehistoric record of the Sun is a Sun symbol in the Lascaux Cave in France, dating back about 16,500 years. More than 2,300 years ago, Qu Yuan posed over 170 questions in Heavenly Questions, including how the universe evolved from chaos into something with form.
- Qu Yuan also asked how far the Sun traveled in a day from rising in Tang Valley to setting at Mengsi, and why the northwestern sky was already brilliantly lit before the Sun had risen. Wang Jingxiu connects the latter question to auroras: when the Sun erupts, brilliant auroras can appear even in the night sky.
- According to the lecture, China could already record and predict total solar eclipses in 2137 BCE. Around 400 BCE, Gan De used pinhole imaging to observe sunspots. Gan De also worked with Wu Xian and Shi Shen to compile what the lecture calls the first star catalog in human history. A historical record from 28 BCE describes a patch of dark vapor the size of a copper coin at the center of the rising Sun.
- In 1424, Zhu Gaochi, the Hongxi Emperor of the Ming dynasty, drew the distribution of sunspots by hand. The unpublished manuscript is now held at Cambridge University Library in the UK. About 500 years later, in 1925, China had another sunspot record, this time drawn by hand after observations through a telescope.
- Copernicus’s On the Revolutions of the Heavenly Spheres challenged the geocentric model with a heliocentric one in which Earth orbits the Sun. Later, the planetary observations Tycho made with the naked eye allowed Kepler to formulate his three laws of planetary motion. Galileo began using a telescope to observe celestial objects, and Newton built on Kepler’s laws to discover the law of universal gravitation and develop Newtonian mechanics.
- Three examples of modern Chinese astronomical instruments are the solar magnetic field telescope at the Huairou Solar Observing Station, LAMOST (the Guo Shoujing Telescope), and the 500-meter-aperture radio telescope known as China’s Sky Eye. More than 5,000 planetary systems have been discovered in the Milky Way. Our solar system is not the only one, and the revolution in astronomy that began with Copernicus is still going on.
Nuclear fusion in the Sun and a little Sun on Earth
- Nuclear fusion takes place in the Sun’s core: four hydrogen nuclei ultimately fuse into one helium nucleus, releasing a large amount of energy and producing particles such as positrons and neutrinos.
- Energy released in the core first moves outward as radiation. At the bottom of the convection zone, radiation can no longer carry heat outward easily, and the heated solar material begins to circulate by convection. Beyond the convection zone are the photosphere, the chromosphere, and the corona, in that order. The corona reaches temperatures of a million degrees, and all these outer layers get their energy from nuclear reactions inside the Sun.
- The Sun radiates energy into space at a rate of 3.86 × 10²⁶ watts. The lecture puts the solar constant at about 1,367 watts per square meter, with very little variation. The energy the Sun releases in one second is equivalent to about 5 million years of total energy use in the United States.
- In 1938, Hans Bethe proposed that the Sun continually generates energy by fusing hydrogen nuclei into helium nuclei. The theory advanced research on stellar structure and evolution, and he received the Nobel Prize in Physics in 1967 for this work. Chandrasekhar and Fowler also received the Nobel Prize in Physics in 1983 for their research on stars.
- The way the Sun generates energy inspired controlled nuclear fusion experiments on Earth. The goal is to use hydrogen fusion in the lab as a sustained source of clean energy. China has built a fully superconducting experimental fusion tokamak. According to the lecture, the device maintained a controlled plasma for 1,056 seconds, setting a world record at the time, and can reach temperatures above 100 million degrees.
Magnetic fields, solar eruptions, and space weather
- Extrapolating measurements of the Sun’s surface magnetic field into three dimensions shows that magnetic field lines at the Sun’s poles are open, while those at the centers of its activity belts are closed. Complex interactions between magnetic fields allow energy to build up in the solar atmosphere, and its release produces various kinds of solar activity. In 1908, George Hale used the Zeeman effect to measure sunspot magnetic fields of more than 4,500 gauss, based on how much atomic spectral lines split in a magnetic field.
- The Sun’s magnetic field appears mainly by emerging from its interior. Regions of positive and negative polarity gradually separate and interact, and violent eruptions can occur locally, generating hard X-rays. A sudden release of a large amount of energy in one area of the Sun, sometimes producing high-energy radiation, is called a solar flare.
- A solar eruption can start with increased radiation from an active region and a flare, then progress to the ejection of coronal material into interplanetary space. When beams of high-energy particles from the eruption strike a satellite detector, they can fill its images with dense, snow-like speckles.
- A coronal mass ejection carries tangled magnetic field lines and solar fluid, forming a magnetic cloud in interplanetary space. The cloud strikes Earth’s magnetopause, tears apart Earth’s magnetic field lines, and feeds energy into the magnetotail. After magnetic reconnection occurs in the magnetotail, high-energy particles are carried to both poles, producing auroras.
- Solar eruptions can induce strong voltages and currents in large power grids. In severe cases, they can burn out parts of the grid and cause widespread blackouts. A solar eruption in March 1989 left the entire Canadian province of Quebec without power for nine hours. Changes in the near-Earth space environment caused by solar activity are called space weather.
- Small-scale magnetic fields of positive and negative polarity are widespread outside sunspots as well. They too can trigger strong eruptions, and ultraviolet observations can reveal this small-scale activity. The one-meter vacuum solar telescope in Yunnan captured structures such as prominences or filaments, as well as spicules that keep appearing on the Sun’s surface. These needle-like jets are another kind of small-scale eruption.
From Alfvén waves to multimessenger astronomy
- Observations of the Sun and space gave Swedish scientist Hannes Alfvén an opportunity to study fluids in magnetic fields. He found that when such a fluid is disturbed, it produces waves like an elastic string. These waves later became known as Alfvén waves.
- Research on Alfvén waves spans plasma physics, astrophysics, and nuclear reactions. Observations of the Sun and its activity helped advance magnetohydrodynamics, and Alfvén received the 1970 Nobel Prize in Physics for his contributions.
- Nuclear reactions inside the Sun produce neutrinos. Because neutrinos have a very small scattering cross section, they can pass through rock that blocks other particles. In 1968, Davis observed solar neutrinos deep in an abandoned mine in the United States. He detected only one-third of the number predicted by theory, raising doubts about whether the solar model was correct.
- Another possible explanation for the solar neutrino deficit was that neutrinos might oscillate among three flavors. At the time, however, the standard model of particle physics held that neutrinos had no mass and therefore could not oscillate. Experiments by Kajita and McDonald confirmed neutrino oscillation, showing that neutrinos have rest mass. The two received the 2015 Nobel Prize in Physics for the discovery. Davis and Koshiba, who detected neutrinos from a supernova, received the prize in 2002.
- Research on solar neutrinos advanced particle physics and led to multimessenger astronomy. Studying the universe no longer relies only on light and other electromagnetic radiation, but also combines observations of neutrinos, cosmic rays, and gravitational waves. The lecture predicts that more phenomena involving high-energy neutrinos and high-energy gravitational waves will be discovered in the future.
The origin of life and the habitability of exoplanets
- Astrobiology studies whether life exists beyond Earth and what forms it might take. Research on the origin of life asks which molecules might give rise to life and what the earliest, simplest life was like.
- Solar physicists have proposed that about 4.1 billion years ago, frequent, violent X-ray and gamma-ray outbursts from the Sun may have acted as a catalyst, helping organic molecules form in rocks on early Earth. The speaker cites a 2022 study, saying that basaltic glass on early Earth contained large amounts of RNA, and notes that RNA may have been the earliest genetic material.
- In December 2020, Hayabusa2 brought samples from the asteroid Ryugu back to Earth. The samples weighed only 4.5 grams in total, yet more than 20 kinds of amino acids were detected in them.
- Mayor and his student Queloz shared the 2019 Nobel Prize in Physics for discovering the first exoplanet orbiting a Sun-like star. The lecture mentions that by then, some 5,000 or more exoplanet systems had been discovered, and the first planetary system outside the Milky Way had also been reported.
- A habitable-zone diagram uses the star’s surface temperature and the planet’s distance from the star as its two axes. The Sun’s surface temperature is a little over 5,800 degrees, and Earth falls within its habitable zone. But this classification is based on whether a planet can have water, so it cannot tell us on its own whether life could exist there.
- The speaker points out that life needs not only water but also a suitable electromagnetic environment. Earth’s magnetosphere can shield it from high-energy particles in the solar wind and help keep the solar wind from stripping oxygen molecules out of the atmosphere. The speaker contrasts Earth with Mars to show why assessing habitability also means considering whether a planet can withstand stellar wind.
The edge of the heliosphere and new opportunities for observation
- The solar wind carves out a vast, cocoon-like region in the space of the Milky Way called the heliosphere. We live in the Sun’s outer atmosphere, and coronal mass ejections, flares, and high-energy particle storms all affect the environment we live in. In 1977, the US Jet Propulsion Laboratory launched Voyager 1 and Voyager 2. The two probes crossed the boundary of the heliosphere one after the other.
- The lecture predicts that the nuclear batteries on Voyager 1 and Voyager 2 will run out in 2027. The probes will keep traveling after that and may even collect data, but Earth will no longer receive their signals.
- The solar system is currently surrounded by four plasma clouds made of partially ionized gas. These clouds interact with the Sun, and radiation from more distant clouds also affects the solar environment. A study published in 2019 proposed that the solar system makes one orbit around the Milky Way every two hundred million years or so, and that its surroundings may change periodically as a result. Some plasma environments may make it harder for life on Earth to reproduce and might even be linked to extinctions.
- Research on the Sun, other stars, and the worlds around them bears on the origin of life and habitability. Gravitational waves, dark matter, and dark energy are also major questions in astronomy. At the time of the lecture, the 6.5-meter James Webb Space Telescope had finished commissioning in space and was ready to begin observations. Its sunshield is about the size of a soccer field.
- Solar Orbiter, a joint European and US mission, will fly over the Sun’s polar regions. Another probe, which has already entered the solar atmosphere, will make direct measurements from about nine solar radii away, and a separate telescope with a 10-meter aperture will study the Sun’s fine structure. China plans to launch a space-based solar observatory to measure magnetic fields, take hard X-ray and Lyman-alpha images, and observe coronal mass ejections.
- Astronomy is driven by observations, so developing major observational instruments is crucial, and theoretical research must move forward alongside it. The lecture cites Peebles’s work on the formation of large-scale structure in the universe, Penrose’s theory of black hole formation, and Parisi’s theory of complex systems, pointing out that after a gap of 36 years, theoretical work once again earned the Nobel Prize in Physics three years in a row.
What it answers
- How does the Sun keep giving off light and heat?
- The Sun’s core fuses hydrogen nuclei into helium nuclei, releasing a large amount of energy. The energy first travels outward as radiation, then is carried farther out by convection.
- Why do solar eruptions cause auroras on Earth?
- When the magnetic cloud formed by a coronal mass ejection hits Earth’s magnetosphere, it can feed energy into the magnetotail. Magnetic reconnection allows high-energy particles to reach the poles, producing auroras.
- Why does the solar neutrino deficit matter?
- The number detected was only about one-third of the theoretical prediction, which for a time cast doubt on the solar model. Later experiments confirmed that neutrinos oscillate and have rest mass, showing that observations of the Sun can also test theories in particle physics.
- If a planet is in the habitable zone, does it have the conditions needed for life to survive?
- Not necessarily. Defining the habitable zone by whether water can exist considers only one condition. Using Earth’s magnetosphere as an example, the speaker emphasizes that an electromagnetic environment that blocks high-energy particles and protects the atmosphere is also important.
Quotes
所以太阳从来没有安静过。
So the Sun has never been quiet.
像绿色的草场和原始森林,太阳的米粒、黑子和高雅飘逸的日珥呈现了大自然纯粹的美丽,给予那些致力于研究它的人们以美学的欢乐和科学的挑战。
Like green pastures and old-growth forests, the Sun’s granules, sunspots, and gracefully floating prominences show the pure beauty of nature, offering those who devote themselves to studying it both aesthetic delight and scientific challenges.
可是生命的存在呢,不只需要水。
But life needs more than just water.
到我们今天触摸太阳的帕克探针,那么人类对太阳、对自己家园的探索呢,从来没有停息过。
All the way to today’s Parker Solar Probe, which touches the Sun, humanity has never stopped exploring the Sun and our own home.
Mentioned
- 汪景琇 — The speaker, from the National Astronomical Observatories of the Chinese Academy of Sciences and the University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, uses research on the Sun as a thread connecting several scientific fields.
- 《天问》 — A poem by Qu Yuan whose questions about the Sun, Moon, stars, and climate show how people in ancient times explored the natural world.
- 哥白尼 — A key figure in the lecture’s account of the revolution in astronomy, he proposed the heliocentric model in On the Revolutions of the Heavenly Spheres.
- 汉斯·贝特 — The speaker explains that he showed in 1938 how hydrogen fusion powers the Sun from within and received the Nobel Prize in Physics in 1967.
- 乔治·海尔 — He used the Zeeman effect in 1908 to measure sunspot magnetic fields. The speaker calls him the first person to measure a magnetic field beyond Earth.
- Hannes Alfvén — The Swedish scientist who advanced magnetohydrodynamics and studied waves that later became known as Alfvén waves.
- Davis — He observed solar neutrinos in an abandoned mine and detected about one-third of the number predicted by theory.
- 多信使天文学 — An approach to studying the universe that uses not just electromagnetic radiation but also signals such as neutrinos, gravitational waves, and cosmic rays.
- 天体生物学 — The lecture introduces it as the field that explores whether life exists beyond Earth and what forms it might take.
- 旅行者一号、旅行者二号 — Two probes launched in 1977. The speaker uses their journeys across the heliosphere’s boundary to show how far human exploration has reached.
- James Webb望远镜 — The 6.5-meter-aperture space telescope cited in the lecture as an example of the opportunities opened up by a new generation of major observational instruments.
- 帕克探针 — A spacecraft that ventures deep into the solar atmosphere to make measurements. The speaker describes its mission as “touching the Sun.”