
#236 云的罗曼蒂克命运消亡史
www.xiaoyuzhoufm.com31:03Chinese
Chapters
This episode of Sheng Dong Ji Xi goes from cloud seeding to air pollution, pointing out that humans have long been able to affect clouds and rainfall but still struggle to predict them, let alone control them at will.
Overview
#236 云的罗曼蒂克命运消亡史
- The episode uses an analogy involving Helen to introduce “cloud stealing,” then draws on Bergeron’s observations in a Norwegian mountain forest to explain why water vapor needs condensation nuclei.
- The hosts explain what it means to “seed” a cloud and use their interview with Ji Zongwei to clarify that cloud seeding can only take place when suitable clouds are already present.
- Dani Rosenfeld’s flights show the risks of taking measurements inside clouds, while Israel’s decision to end its cloud-seeding program shows how hard it is to attribute and quantify extra rainfall.
- The episode explains why aerosols from everyday emissions may suppress rainfall or contribute to torrential rain, and how different particles and cloud layers make the climate effects harder to pin down.
- The show announces that Dai Jinhua and Fang Kecheng received the most votes and says it will send invitations and agree on a time for the livestream.
Key points
- Bergeron found that mountain stratus clouds often stayed above the treetops when temperatures were below freezing. His observations raised the question of how condensation nuclei help water vapor condense.
- Cloud seeding does not make rain out of thin air. First, you have to wait for the right clouds. Ji Zongwei says crews have waited on standby for as long as 48 hours.
- Flying into clouds to take measurements can mean encountering strong convection, lightning, and sudden vertical air currents. Dani Rosenfeld once measured liquid water at −38°C in a cloud over Texas.
- Israel ended its cloud-seeding program not because it concluded that the technology did not work, but because it was hard to separate the extra rainfall from natural fluctuations and therefore hard to tell whether it was worth the cost. It turned instead to more controllable seawater purification.
- When the total amount of water vapor stays the same, more condensation nuclei spread the moisture across more cloud droplets, making them smaller and making it harder for rain to form. When water vapor is plentiful, the episode suggests that large amounts of aerosols may also contribute to torrential rain.
- Different aerosols and different types of clouds have different effects. Black carbon absorbs solar radiation and may suppress cloud formation. The episode also notes that thicker low clouds can have a cooling effect, while cirrus clouds can have a warming effect.
Chapter notes
From rumors of cloud stealing to condensation nuclei
- The episode likens the clouds being fought over to Helen, who sparked the Trojan War in Greek mythology. The image of “stealing clouds as if you were pulling apart cotton candy” raises two questions: When did clouds become something people fight over, and what technologies do humans have to influence the weather?
- The episode puts the turning point for clouds around 1900. Before then, people could only pray for rain. Afterward, scientists began studying how clouds and rainfall form. The textbook explanation that “water vapor rises, cools and condenses into tiny droplets, then falls” is only a simplified version.
- In the winter of 1922, Swedish atmospheric physicist Tor Bergeron was recuperating on a mountain 470 meters above sea level in Oslo, Norway. He often walked through the pine forest observing clouds and fog. He found that at temperatures between −5 and −10°C, stratus clouds usually stayed above the treetops. Above freezing, by contrast, fog spread all the way to the forest floor and grew so thick that he could not see even 5 meters ahead.
- Bergeron guessed that the cold stratus clouds, which had not yet produced rain or snow, still held a great deal of water vapor. As soon as the vapor touched the ice and snow on the branches, it condensed into frost, so it never spread down to the forest floor.
- Li Jing of Peking University’s Department of Atmospheric and Oceanic Sciences explains that reaching saturation is not enough. For droplets to form on their own, water vapor levels need to be several times the saturation level. With condensation nuclei, droplets can form more easily. The dust, ice, and snow on the treetops that Bergeron observed acted as condensation nuclei. Airborne dust, tiny ice crystals, and sea salt particles over the ocean can do the same.
Why cloud seeding has to wait for clouds
- Cloud seeding adds condensation nuclei to clouds. Silver iodide was chosen because its structure resembles that of tiny ice crystals. The “seeding” in the English term “cloud seeding” means sowing seeds: the condensation nuclei are scattered into clouds like seeds.
- Cloud seeding can bring more rain to farmland during droughts, or it can be used to try to get rain to fall before a major sporting event. To find out how Middle Eastern countries “steal clouds,” the hosts found pilots, radar specialists, and other people working in the field on LinkedIn, but none replied to their interview requests.
- Ji Zongwei, a meteorological bureau official in Shaoxing, Zhejiang, points out that cloud seeding does not make rain out of a clear sky. Operations can only begin once suitable clouds are detected. If crews find no suitable clouds on site or the earlier forecast turns out to be wrong, they have to wait for the next batch. They have waited on standby for 24 hours, and even 48 hours.
- Ground-based smoke generators use rising air on windward slopes to carry seeding agents such as silver iodide, released by burning smoke sticks, into clouds. Rockets can deliver the seeding agents to the target cloud layer more accurately, but the rockets used are classified as civilian explosives and are closely regulated by public security authorities.
- Aircraft can fly directly into the target clouds to disperse seeding agents, which is more precise but requires coordinating a large area of airspace. Zhejiang has a lot of commercial flights, so it does not use aircraft for cloud seeding. According to media reports cited in the episode, countries such as Iran keep crews on standby so that pilots can take off as soon as suitable clouds are spotted, day or night.
Flying into clouds and weighing the cost of cloud seeding
- Dani Rosenfeld, who teaches at the Hebrew University in Israel, began studying how rain forms more than 30 years ago. He wanted to measure exactly how much extra water people could get from clouds. To do that, he flew with pilots into clouds over Israel, the United States, South America, Thailand, and India to take measurements.
- Some clouds have strong convection and lightning at their cores, so the team avoided those areas. They chose clouds that were still forming, relatively isolated, and clearly defined at the edges so they could plan where to enter and exit. Even then, sudden vertical air currents inside a cloud could send the plane lurching up and down like an elevator. Anyone without a seat belt could hit the cabin ceiling.
- Rosenfeld’s flights had no accidents, and he once found liquid water at −38°C in a cloud over Texas, earning a Guinness World Record. By contrast, Bergeron’s colleague and close friend Carl Wigand died in 1925 when his plane ran into trouble during an observation flight. After that, Bergeron never flew again to observe clouds up close.
- Israel did not end its cloud-seeding program because cloud seeding was ineffective, but because variables in the natural environment cannot be controlled the way they can in a lab. A great deal of data was collected each time, but the results varied widely. For example, a huge, moisture-laden cloud mass carrying cold air can also bring extra rain, and that rain cannot be credited to cloud seeding.
- Because scientists and program operators could not calculate exactly how much extra rain was due to human intervention, they could not tell whether that rainfall justified the cost. Israel therefore switched to more controllable seawater purification.
How pollution changes clouds and rain
- In a paper published in Science in 2000, Professor Rosenfeld pointed out that pollutants emitted by humans are changing clouds. By aerosols, the episode means particles or liquid droplets suspended in the air.
- Aerosols from everyday emissions can act as condensation nuclei, allowing more cloud droplets to form. But if the total amount of water vapor stays the same, the moisture is spread across more droplets. The smaller the droplets, the longer they take to grow big enough to fall as rain. A cloud that would otherwise have produced rain may not rain at all.
- If water vapor is very plentiful, more condensation nuclei can produce more cloud droplets, and those droplets can keep growing, potentially causing sudden torrential rain. Rosenfeld and other scientists suspect that exceptionally heavy summer rain in some normally drier inland areas may be linked to large amounts of aerosols encountering warm, moist air.
- Rosenfeld speculates that by changing clouds, pollutants may already have affected the global climate in ways that are not yet clear. Aerosols are not a single substance, and different components affect clouds differently.
- After absorbing solar radiation, black carbon heats the surrounding air. This makes moisture that might otherwise condense into cloud droplets more likely to evaporate, suppressing cloud formation. But under natural conditions, wind can also blow clouds away, making it hard to measure how much cloud cover was lost because of black carbon alone.
- Different cloud layers also affect atmospheric temperatures differently. Thicker low clouds usually have a cooling effect, while cirrus clouds have a warming effect because they absorb infrared radiation.
Anniversary livestream poll results
- The results of the guest poll for Shengdong Huopo’s anniversary livestream are in. Dai Jinhua and Fang Kecheng got the most votes. Li Ruyi, Ma Boyong, and others were also close, with gaps of no more than five votes.
- The team mistakenly included Dai Jinhua on the list of potential returning guests even though she had never appeared on Sheng Dong Ji Xi, and apologized to listeners for the error. She still received the most votes of any guest.
- The team will invite Dai Jinhua and Fang Kecheng as soon as possible, finalize the time, and invite members to join the final live recording under the rules announced earlier. Other guests who received listener votes may also be invited next year.
- The team says listeners’ support made it possible to spend a month and a half repeatedly scrapping and revising this episode about clouds. They also thank intern Lin Yun for fact-checking and reviewing the audio.
What it answers
- Why does water vapor in clouds need condensation nuclei?
- Li Jing explains that water vapor needs a very high degree of supersaturation to form droplets on its own. Dust, sea salt particles, and tiny ice crystals can help it condense.
- Can cloud seeding make heavy rain fall from a clear sky?
- No. Crews first have to find suitable clouds. If conditions on site do not match the forecast, all they can do is wait for the next batch.
- Why did Israel end its cloud-seeding program?
- Natural weather has too many variables. The program struggled to calculate exactly how much extra rain the operations produced, so it was hard to tell whether the benefits outweighed the costs. The episode says Israel therefore turned to more controllable seawater purification.
- Why can pollution both suppress rainfall and contribute to torrential rain?
- When water vapor is limited, more condensation nuclei divide up the available moisture, making it harder for individual cloud droplets to grow big enough to fall. When water vapor is very plentiful, the episode suggests that many droplets may grow at the same time, contributing to torrential rain.
Quotes
没有合适的云,一切都不会发生。
Without the right clouds, none of this can happen.
这个单词会让我想到云可以像农作物一样被人类所驯化和改良。
The word makes me think that people could domesticate and improve clouds just like crops.
但我们可能想要获得的云朵中的那些雨水,未必就是我们所预期的。
But the rainwater we might want to get from those clouds may not be what we expect.
Mentioned
- 声东击西 — A podcast that explores clouds and cloud seeding through conversation and interviews.
- 徐涛 — The host of this episode.
- Amanda — The producer of Sheng Dong Ji Xi and a co-host for this episode.
- 伯杰隆 — A Swedish atmospheric physicist whose observations of clouds and fog while recuperating in Norway are used in the episode to introduce condensation nuclei.
- 李晶 — A researcher from Peking University’s Department of Atmospheric and Oceanic Sciences who was interviewed about the role of condensation nuclei and aerosols in forming cloud droplets. The name Li Jing is written as 李菁 later in the transcript.
- 吉宗伟 — A meteorological bureau official in Shaoxing, Zhejiang, who explained what cloud conditions are needed for cloud seeding.
- Dani Rosenfeld — A professor at the Hebrew University in Israel who studies how rain forms and how pollutants affect clouds and the atmosphere.
- 凝结核 — Particles that help water vapor condense. Examples in the episode include dust, sea salt particles, and tiny ice crystals.
- 人工增雨 — An attempt to increase precipitation by adding seeding agents to suitable clouds, rather than making rain out of a clear sky.
- 气溶胶 — Particles or liquid droplets suspended in the air, some of which can act as condensation nuclei.
- 黑碳 — The episode uses it to show how certain particles absorb solar radiation and heat the surrounding air, potentially suppressing cloud formation.