1. Introduction to Human Behavioral Biology
Stanford57:142011-02-01English
Chapters
This is the introductory lecture for Stanford University’s Human Behavioral Biology course. The most useful approach is to describe the behavior first, then trace it back from immediate neural activity through the environment, development, and evolution, rather than treating any one level as the whole explanation.
Overview
1. Introduction to Human Behavioral Biology
- The lecturer uses a hypothetical case of a man whose personality suddenly changes, classroom polls, and court cases to show that physiology affects the brain and that thoughts can change the state of the body.
- From colors, speech sounds, and passing grades to phone numbers and sequences of subway stops, the lecturer shows how categories can aid memory while distorting our sense of differences and of the whole.
- Using the example of a hen crossing the road, the lecturer shows how a single behavior can connect neural activity, sensory stimuli, hormones, development, genetics, and evolution.
- The lecturer uses behaviorism, lobotomy, and racist propaganda to illustrate the danger of treating a partial explanation as the whole truth.
- Using synchronized ovulation, stress during chess matches, language, and sexual behavior, the lecturer distinguishes shared mechanisms, distinctive uses of those mechanisms, and behaviors that may be uniquely human.
- The course starts with separate introductions to each discipline, then brings them together to explain specific behaviors. It offers catch-up sessions and regular discussion sections for students without a relevant background.
- The lecturer explains how the assigned book Chaos challenges reductionism and describes the online arrangements for papers, handouts, lecture notes, and some slides.
- The lecturer introduces the TAs and the different levels of discussion sections, and answers questions about the five credits, recordings, exam dates, and exam format.
Key points
- The state of the body can have a major effect on the brain. Conversely, just thinking about your own death can make a previously steady heartbeat speed up.
- Categories make it easier to remember things and make judgments, but they can also hide differences within a category, exaggerate differences across its boundaries, and make people miss the big picture.
- To explain a behavior, first describe it objectively, then ask in turn about immediate neural activity, sensory stimuli, hormonal state, early and fetal development, genetics, and evolutionary pressures.
- Genes, hormones, neurons, and the environment are not competing answers. Each level is a convenient way to describe, at that point in time, the combined effects of what came before.
- The lecturer uses John Watson, Egas Moniz, and Konrad Lorenz as cautionary examples, pointing out that even influential scientists can cause serious harm by treating a single framework as a complete explanation.
- When comparing humans with other animals, distinguish three cases: humans resemble other animals; humans use similar physiological mechanisms to do different things; and humans display behaviors that the lecturer believes have no precedent in other animals.
- The first half of the course introduces the tools of each discipline separately. The second half applies them to topics such as sexual behavior, aggression, parental behavior, psychiatric disorders, and language. The midterm emphasizes fundamentals, while the final emphasizes integrating ideas across disciplines.
Chapter notes
What Unusual Behavior Reveals About the Mind and Body
- A 40-year-old married man who had led a quiet life suddenly hits a coworker at work. Three months later, his wife finds out he is having an affair with a 16-year-old Safeway cashier. Another three months later, he takes off with money from his workplace and disappears. Besides bad character and an immature midlife crisis, the lecturer offers a third explanation: a neurological disorder caused by an abnormality in a single gene that happens to produce this pattern of behavior.
- In a show-of-hands poll, the lecturer asks whether events before birth can affect political views 30 years later, whether biology can explain religious belief, and whether students believe in free will. In the end, the lecturer endorses neither nature nor nurture as the sole determinant, but emphasizes the complex and subtle interplay between them.
- Menstruation, brain tumors, eating large amounts of junk food, and using anabolic steroids have one surprising thing in common: all have been used successfully in court to explain why someone killed. In some cases, the defendant was menstruating at the time of the killing, and the jury took that as part of its reason for acquitting them.
- The lecturer notes that the amygdala is involved in aggression and fear, and that tumors in this area have been used to explain uncontrolled violence. The famous “Twinkie defense” in the Dan White case argued that junk food addiction caused sharp swings in blood sugar, which in turn led to the killings. Other cases have attributed uncontrolled violence to anabolic steroid abuse.
- These cases lead to the course’s first point: changes in the body can sometimes have a major effect on the brain. Conversely, when you’re relaxed before bed and your heart is beating slowly, just thinking that it will stop one day and then imagining your lips turning blue, your blood flow slowing, and your feet getting cold can make your heart beat faster.
- The course examines the two-way relationship between physiological states and behavior, and how emotions, thoughts, and memories are involved: in all sorts of situations, the body and mind can profoundly change one another.
The Benefits and Pitfalls of Thinking in Categories
- The biology of human social behavior is complicated. To make judgments easier, people often divide things that vary continuously into categories and give them labels. For example, running a mile in under 4 minutes seems impressive, but knowing that a painter used 11 colors tells you nothing about how good the painting is, because people don’t rate paintings by the number of colors used.
- Categories ease the burden on memory: it is easier to remember that a color is “orange” than to remember its exact features. Different languages draw the boundaries of the color spectrum in different places. People are better at remembering whether they have seen a shade near the center of a color category in their native language than one near its edge.
- Languages also categorize sounds that vary continuously in different ways, and sounds placed in the same category are easy to confuse. The lecturer recalls that a Finnish urologist meant to suggest practicing with a pear, but the lecturer heard “bear” and only understood when the doctor said an apple would work too.
- Categories can also exaggerate differences across a boundary. A score of 65 is only 1 point below 66, but if one is a fail and the other is a pass, they can feel worlds apart.
- In a phone number dictation exercise, the lecturer first reads out numbers in the usual three-digit, four-digit format, then breaks that pattern and expects accuracy to drop sharply. Once listeners are busy working out how to group the digits, they can easily miss what comes next and lose sight of the full sequence.
- Given 4th, 14th, 23rd, and 34th, people familiar with the New York subway recognize the sequence of stops and answer 42nd, while others look for a numerical pattern. The lecturer sums up: thinking in categories can make people underestimate differences within a category, exaggerate differences across a boundary, and miss the big picture.
From Immediate Triggers Back to Evolution
- The hen crosses the road to run toward a rooster performing a courtship display. The same behavior can be explained at several levels: her estrogen levels make a key part of the hypothalamus responsive to the courtship stimulus, her pelvic structure allows her to run, and over the course of evolution, chickens that did not respond to courtship displays left fewer copies of their genes.
- Putting a behavior into a single explanatory category makes it harder to judge how facts are alike or different and to see the big picture. It also encourages people to overestimate the importance of whatever they know best and attribute everything to a gene, a neurotransmitter, or a childhood trauma. The course examines how the body affects behavior, emotions, and memory, and how they in turn affect the body.
- When analyzing a behavior, first describe objectively what it actually looks like. Then ask which neurons and neural circuits were active in the half-second before it happened and helped bring it about. After identifying the active brain region, ask what smell, sound, or other sensory stimulus in the environment activated those neurons.
- Go further back and ask how hormone levels over the preceding few hours changed the individual’s sensitivity to those stimuli. Follow that line of inquiry back through early development, the fetal period, the genetic makeup of the individual as well as the whole population and species, and evolutionary pressures.
- These levels are not independent explanations. Explaining a behavior in terms of a hormone leads back to the gene that encodes it and the selection that gene underwent. Explaining an immediate trigger in terms of a smell or a visual stimulus leads back to fetal development, which shapes sensory sensitivity. Each level is only a temporary stopping point, a convenient way to describe the combined result of all the influences that came before.
The Historical Cost of Single Explanations
- In 1912, John Watson, one of the founders of behaviorism, claimed that with complete control over a child’s upbringing, he could turn any child into a doctor, a lawyer, a beggar, or a thief. In the 1950s, B.F. Skinner took this emphasis on rewards, punishments, and positive and negative reinforcement to its height. The lecturer uses severe protein deficiency during fetal development as a counterexample to the idea that rewards and punishments alone can shape behavior however one wishes.
- The Portuguese neurologist Egas Moniz attributed psychiatric disorders to problems with the synapses between brain cells. When he received the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine for inventing the lobotomy, he claimed that this so-called “synaptic adjustment” could only lead to a cure or improvement and would never fail.
- The lecturer points out that tens of thousands, if not hundreds of thousands, of people underwent lobotomies even though there was nothing wrong with them. He calls this large-scale brain damage a dark chapter in the alliance between psychiatry and ideology.
- Konrad Lorenz, one of the founders of ethology, was famous for discovering imprinting in birds, but he was also one of Hitler’s main scientific propagandists. Drawing on racial ideas, he advocated eliminating people he deemed “inferior” and went to his grave believing he had done nothing wrong.
- The lecturer stresses that these were not insignificant scientists. Their ideas shaped educational decisions, led to the destruction of hundreds of thousands of people’s brains, and fueled the idea that murdering 9 million people could solve a problem that did not exist. The course therefore aims to resist the temptation to treat a partial explanation as the whole truth. Even when faced with the most disturbing human behaviors, we cannot look for answers within just one framework.
Three Ways to Compare Humans with Other Animals
- When trying to understand human social behavior, genes, hormones, neurons, and the environment are not separate categories of explanation. Each level is a convenient way to sum up the influences that came before. The first challenge is to recognize that sometimes humans are no different from other animals.
- Female hamsters normally ovulate about once every five days. After two females share a cage for about a month, their cycles gradually lengthen, and they often end up ovulating on the same afternoon. The lecturer attributes this synchronization to airborne pheromones detected through smell and notes that it does not happen if the sense of smell is blocked.
- According to the lecturer, male hamster pheromones shorten female hamsters’ cycles and disrupt synchronization. When two females share a cage, the dominant one usually sets the pace for the other. He compares this with a phenomenon reported at Wellesley in 1970: first-year women living together tended to have longer cycles that synchronized, but those with an impaired sense of smell did not synchronize, and those who were intimate with men fell out of sync.
- The second challenge is to see how humans use the same physiological mechanisms as other animals in different ways. Chess grandmasters do little more than sit, think, and move pieces, yet they can sustain blood pressure comparable to a marathon runner’s for six hours straight and burn thousands of calories in a day. The lecturer compares this stress response to the physiological response of a male baboon after an intense fight.
- Humans can experience stress just by thinking about their own eventual death or reading about something bad happening to a fictional character. The same mechanisms of emotional connection also let people feel for strangers in a refugee camp halfway around the world or feel upset about an injured pet. What is distinctive is not the physiological mechanism itself, but what can trigger it.
- The third challenge is to understand behaviors with no close counterpart in other animals. The lecturer gives the example of a couple having sex 30 nights in a row and talking afterward, noting that nonreproductive sex this frequent is rare in the animal kingdom. He identifies language, some aspects of sexual behavior, and the harm caused when some people combine sex and aggression as phenomena that need to be understood in their own right.
Course Structure and Support for Beginners
- The course repeatedly warns students not to treat disciplinary categories as the limits of an explanation, because that kind of thinking can have serious consequences in areas of science where much is at stake. Humans and other species share many physiological mechanisms, but use them in very different ways. Some human behaviors have no precedent in other species. The course asks how biology can explain these phenomena.
- The first half of the term introduces each discipline in turn: evolutionary theory, the relationship between molecular genetics and behavior, behavioral genetics, ethology, the brain, and endocrinology. The course moves to a new field roughly every two and a half lectures, so students often have to start learning a new set of terms just as they get used to the last one.
- The second half of the term crosses disciplinary boundaries to explain topics such as sexual behavior, aggression, parental behavior, schizophrenia, depression, personality disorders, and language use. The analysis starts with the phenomenon itself and traces it back through the neural activity a second before it happens, the sensory stimuli that trigger the neurons, and all the way to evolutionary selection pressures millions of years ago, examining how factors at different levels interact.
- The course has no prerequisites and is open to complete beginners. In addition to regular weekly discussion and review, the first half of the term offers a weekly catch-up session for students without a background in the relevant field. The first session, on evolutionary theory, will be led by a TA familiar with the field. It is scheduled for this Thursday at 7:30 in the room next door, to go with the Wednesday and Friday lectures on evolution. Students unfamiliar with the terms on the handout can attend.
- For students without a science background, taking the course pass/fail, if that option is available, can take some pressure off and let them focus on the material. The lecturer believes behavioral biology is not just for specialists: serving on a jury, voting on whether to fund a solution to a problem, or trying to understand a family member’s depression all require judgments about behavior and what causes it.
- There are about 18 regular discussion sections each week at different times. Students are not assigned to a fixed section and can choose whichever session is convenient. The midterm is scheduled for when the last discipline-specific topic in the first half of the term has been covered. There is also a final exam.
Readings and Online Resources
- Two books are assigned. One is the lecturer’s own book, which is relevant to the second half of the course; recommended chapters will be listed when the time comes. The other is James Gleick’s Chaos.
- Chaos challenges a reductionist approach that has been used for about 500 years: take a complex system apart, understand each piece, then put it back together to understand the whole. That works for fixing a clock, but not for understanding behavior. Behavior is more like a cloud: taking a cloud apart and putting it back together does not explain why it rains.
- Much of Chaos draws on the physical sciences rather than biology, so the course will recommend selected chapters. The second half of the course will also include several lectures on chaos and complexity, explaining further how these ideas change the way we understand behavior.
- The lecturer is switching the assigned readings to papers that can be downloaded online and is about halfway done. He hopes students will not have to buy a course reader. If a reader is ultimately needed, it will not be too thick or expensive. Each reading will come with instructions: for some, students will need to read the full paper and understand the details of the study; for others, they will only need to read the abstract to see how researchers in a particular field think about the question.
- Coursework will provide handouts, frequently asked questions, Q&A, the course schedule, some slides, and announcements such as changes to office hours. Lecture notes run about 5 to 10 pages per lecture and are expected to cover only up to the midpoint of the course. The course team is also working on a way for people who are not officially enrolled to access the resources.
- Starting with the next lecture, printed handouts will no longer be distributed to everyone, because even double-sided printing uses about 5,000 sheets per lecture. Materials will be posted on Coursework the day before class. Anyone who has trouble following the lecture without a printed handout can ask the lecturer for a copy.
TA Discussion Sections and Exam Questions
- Discussion sections start this Thursday. The regular section times will be announced, and office hours begin next week. The TAs are graduate students from different specialties who have taken the course, and some have TAed for it before. A few weeks into the course, advanced sections for students with a stronger background will be offered alongside the regular sections that review course material.
- The course is worth 5 credits, mainly because of the long hours in class each week. The lecturer expects the workload to match the credit value. Because each lecture spans two one-hour time slots, many students will miss one of them, so lectures will be recorded and uploaded to Coursework within about a day.
- The midterm is scheduled for Monday, May 3, at 7:30 p.m., outside normal class hours. If the course is on schedule, class time that day will be used for review. The final is on June 4.
- With so many students enrolled, it would be hard for the TAs to grade a large number of essay answers in a short time, so the exams will include quite a few multiple-choice questions. The midterm mainly tests the basics of each discipline, with a little cross-disciplinary thinking. The final focuses entirely on thinking across disciplines.
- There is one required catch-up session before each of the next three lectures. These sessions are expected to be recorded in audio only. The recordings, along with important handouts and diagrams, will be uploaded to CourseWorks. Students can also ask questions during office hours.
- After a correction during class, the final exam’s start time was confirmed as 12:15.
What it answers
- Why can’t a complex behavior be explained by just one gene, one hormone, or one childhood experience?
- Because these levels are connected. The lecturer points out that explaining how a hormone works involves genetics and evolution, and explaining a sensory trigger also involves the early development that shapes sensory sensitivity.
- What is the first step in analyzing a specific behavior?
- First describe the behavior itself as objectively as possible. Then ask what neural activity occurred in the half-second before the behavior and what sensory stimulus activated those neural circuits.
- What three errors in judgment are most likely to result from thinking in categories?
- Underestimating differences within a category, overestimating differences on opposite sides of a category boundary, and missing the big picture because you are focused on the categories.
- Can I take this course without a background in biology?
- Yes. The course has no prerequisites, and the first half includes catch-up sessions to help students learn the basics before moving into topics from different disciplines.
- What do the midterm and final each cover?
- The midterm mainly tests the fundamentals of each discipline, with a few cross-disciplinary questions. The final focuses on whether students can connect explanations from different disciplines. Because the class is large, the exams will have many multiple-choice questions.
Quotes
sometimes the stuff that's going on in your body can dramatically influence what goes on in your brain.
When you think in categories, you overestimate how different they are when there happens to be a boundary in between them, and when you pay attention to categorical boundaries, you don't see big pictures.
They're not even temporary buckets. There's no buckets.
Behavior is not like a clock. Behavior is like a cloud.
Mentioned
- Stanford University — The university offering this introductory Bio 150 lecture.
- Bio 150 — The Human Behavioral Biology course introduced in this lecture. The first half introduces individual disciplines, and the second half brings them together around specific behaviors.
- 杏仁核 — The brain region the lecturer mentions in the court cases, associated with fear and aggression.
- 行为主义 — The lecturer uses it to show that rewards, punishments, and reinforcement alone cannot explain or shape every behavior.
- John Watson — One of the founders of behaviorism, cited by the lecturer for arguing that children can be shaped by controlling the environment in which they grow up.
- B.F. Skinner — The psychologist the lecturer mentions to illustrate the development of behaviorism in the 1950s.
- Egas Moniz — The lecturer uses this Portuguese neurologist and the lobotomy he pioneered to criticize reducing psychiatric problems to faulty synapses.
- Konrad Lorenz — The lecturer presents this cofounder of ethology, who studied imprinting in birds, as a warning about scientific authorities taking part in Nazi propaganda.
- Wellesley 效应 — The name the lecturer uses for the reported tendency of female roommates’ menstrual cycles to synchronize.
- James Gleick — The author of the assigned book Chaos.
- Chaos — The book the lecturer recommends to introduce chaos and complexity and challenge the idea that behavior can be understood simply by taking it apart.
- CourseWorks — The online platform used to post handouts, course materials, and lecture recordings.