Do schools kill creativity? | Sir Ken Robinson | TED
TED20:032007-01-07English
Chapters
In this TED talk, Sir Ken Robinson argues that creativity should be given the same importance as literacy, because children need to be willing to try things and make mistakes if they are to come up with new ways of dealing with an unpredictable future.
Overview
Do schools kill creativity?
- Robinson starts by asking how education can prepare children for an unknown future, then tells stories about drawing and acting that show how children are willing to give things a go even when they do not know the answer.
- He distinguishes making mistakes from being creative, then criticizes schools for making children afraid to get things wrong. He uses the low status of the arts, especially dance, to show how much more weight is given to academic ability.
- He traces the hierarchy of school subjects back to industrialization, points to academic inflation, and rethinks intelligence in terms of its diversity, its dynamic nature, and the ways it differs from person to person.
- He tells how Gillian Lynne went from being suspected of having a learning disability to a career in choreography, and uses her story to call for an education that recognizes all kinds of talent and develops the whole person.
Key points
- Education has to prepare children for an unpredictable future. Robinson argues that since children generally have the potential to innovate, creativity should have the same status as literacy.
- Making mistakes is not the same as being creative, but if you are unwilling to risk being wrong, it is hard to come up with original ideas. Treating mistakes as the worst thing that can happen gradually makes children afraid to try.
- Robinson points out that schools usually put math and languages first, followed by the humanities, with the arts last. Within the arts, visual art and music also tend to get more attention than drama and dance. He attributes this hierarchy to industrial-era ideas about employment and universities' emphasis on academic ability.
- An education geared toward getting into university can lead people who excel in other areas to underestimate their talents. Robinson calls it “academic inflation” when the same kind of job requires increasingly higher qualifications.
- Robinson argues that intelligence is diverse, dynamic, and different from person to person. He defines creativity as the process of coming up with original ideas that have value and notes that such ideas often arise where different disciplinary perspectives meet.
- As a child, Gillian Lynne could not sit still, and her school suspected for a time that she had a learning disability. A specialist saw her dancing to music and recommended that she study dance. Her later career shows that behavior seen as a problem in the classroom can sometimes point to a child's strengths.
Chapter notes
The Unpredictable Future and Children's Creativity
- Robinson draws three themes related to education from the conference: the participants have shown the rich variety of human creativity, the future is hard to predict, and children have an astonishing capacity to innovate.
- Education has to prepare children for a future they cannot foresee. Children starting school that year will retire in 2065, yet even after four days of so many experts sharing their insights, no one knows what the world will look like in five years.
- Sirena's performance was astonishing, but Robinson does not think that having talent is what makes her unique. She discovered her talent and threw herself into it, while every child has enormous talents that we often waste ruthlessly. He argues that creativity should have the same status as literacy in education.
- A six-year-old girl who rarely paid attention was unusually absorbed in a drawing lesson and said she was drawing God. When the teacher said nobody knew what God looked like, she replied, “They will in a minute.”
- Robinson's four-year-old son James played Joseph in a Nativity play, in which the three kings were supposed to bring gold, frankincense, and myrrh. The children seemed to get the order mixed up: the first two said they had brought gold and myrrh, respectively, and the third turned “frankincense” into “Frank sent this.”
From Fear of Mistakes to the Hierarchy of Subjects
- Children will give something a try even if they do not know the answer. Making a mistake is not the same as creating something, but if you are unwilling to risk being wrong, you cannot come up with anything original. Most children grow up to fear making mistakes, and businesses and education systems also treat mistakes as a bad thing.
- Robinson quotes Picasso: every child is born an artist, and the hard part is staying one as you grow up. He argues that we do not acquire creativity as we grow up; we gradually lose it in the process of being educated.
- Robinson observes that education systems everywhere rank subjects the same way: math and languages come first, the humanities next, and the arts last. There is also a hierarchy within the arts: visual art and music usually get more attention than drama and dance. Schools teach math every day, but no education system teaches dance every day in the same way, even though he thinks both matter.
- Children dance whenever they get the chance. But as they grow up, education increasingly focuses only on what is above the waist, until it is concerned almost entirely with the head. Robinson jokes that if alien visitors judged the purpose of education by who was most likely to excel at school, they would probably think public education was designed to produce university professors.
- Robinson was a university professor himself and likes them, but he does not think they should be held up as the highest standard of human achievement. He jokes that some professors seem to live in their heads, and that their bodies are just a way of getting their heads to meetings.
Industrial-Era Education and the Diversity of Intelligence
- Before the 19th century, there were virtually no public education systems anywhere in the world. These systems were set up to meet the needs of industrialization. The hierarchy of subjects was based on two principles: subjects thought to be most useful for getting a job came first, and universities designed the education system around their own standards, making academic ability the main measure of intelligence.
- Children are often discouraged, with good intentions, from pursuing music or visual art they enjoy because those subjects are thought not to lead to jobs. The whole public education system is like one long university admissions process. As a result, many highly talented, creative people underestimate themselves because what they are good at is not valued at school or is even looked down on.
- UNESCO predicts that more people will graduate worldwide in the next 30 years than in all of history up to that point. Robinson attributes this change to technology transforming work and to rapid population growth. He illustrates academic inflation through rising job requirements: a degree used to be enough to get a job, but a position that once required a BA may now require an MA, while other positions require a PhD.
- Academic inflation shows that the structure of education is changing and that we need to rethink intelligence. Intelligence is diverse: we think in all the ways we experience the world, including through images, sounds, bodily sensations, movement, and abstract concepts.
- Intelligence is also dynamic: the brain is not made up of isolated compartments, and thinking depends on different parts interacting. Robinson defines creativity as the process of coming up with original ideas that have value and notes that such ideas often arise when different disciplines' ways of looking at things collide.
- Robinson mentions the corpus callosum, which connects the two hemispheres of the brain, and speculates that its greater thickness in women may be related to the ability to multitask. He jokes about the contrast at home: his wife can answer the phone and talk to the children while cooking, whereas he has to close the door and disconnect the phone just to concentrate on frying an egg.
From a Talent for Dance to Educating the Whole Person
- Everyone's intelligence is unique. While writing Epiphany, Robinson interviewed several people who had discovered their talents. The book was inspired by a conversation with Gillian Lynne, who choreographed Cats and Phantom of the Opera. In the 1930s, however, her school suspected she had a learning disability because she had trouble paying attention and could not sit still.
- At age eight, Gillian went with her mother to see a specialist. After hearing how she disrupted class and always handed in her homework late, among other things, the specialist turned on the radio and asked her mother to step outside with him to watch. Gillian immediately got up and danced to the music. The specialist told her mother, “She's not sick. She's a dancer,” and recommended sending her to dance school.
- At dance school, Gillian met people who, like her, needed to move in order to think, and she learned ballet, tap, jazz, modern dance, and contemporary dance. She later attended the Royal Ballet School, became a soloist with the Royal Ballet, founded the Gillian Lynne Dance Company, and met Andrew Lloyd Webber, going on to work on some hugely successful musical productions. Robinson points out that someone else might simply have put her on medication and told her to quiet down.
- Robinson calls for a new “view of human ecology” that recognizes anew the richness of human ability. Like strip mining for a single resource, the current education system values only certain abilities of the mind. That approach cannot meet the needs of the future, so we have to rethink the basic principles of education.
- Robinson quotes Jonas Salk: if insects disappeared, all life on Earth would die out within 50 years; if humans disappeared, all kinds of life would instead flourish within 50 years. TED celebrates the human imagination, and to use it wisely, we have to recognize the richness of creativity and the hope that children embody.
- Education's task is to develop the whole person so children can face the future. We may not live to see that future, but they will. Our responsibility is to help them make something of it.
What it answers
- Why should creativity be as important as literacy?
- Schools have to prepare children for the world they will face, but it is hard to predict what the world will look like even a few years from now. Robinson argues that education should not waste the capacity for innovation that children already have.
- What does being willing to make mistakes have to do with creativity?
- Making mistakes is not in itself creative, but you have to be willing to risk being wrong to come up with original ideas. If schools make students feel that getting things wrong is the worst thing they can do, they will become increasingly afraid to try.
- Why do the arts often get less attention in school than math and languages?
- As Robinson explains it, the ranking of subjects in public education reflects the employment needs of the industrial era. At the same time, universities shaped the education system around their own standards, making academic ability the main measure of intelligence.
- What does academic inflation mean in the talk?
- It refers to the rising academic qualifications required for jobs. For example, a position that used to require a bachelor's degree might later require a master's degree. Robinson uses this to show that the relationship between qualifications and employment is changing.
- How was Gillian Lynne's talent for dance discovered?
- The specialist turned on the radio before leaving the consulting room, then asked her mother to watch from outside. When he saw Gillian immediately start dancing to the music, he recommended sending her to dance school.
Quotes
My contention is that creativity now is as important in education as literacy, and we should treat it with the same status.
What we do know is if you're not prepared to be wrong, you will never come up with anything original.
I believe this passionately, that we don't grow into creativity, we grow out of it.
And our task is to educate their whole being so they can face this future.
Mentioned
- Sir Ken Robinson — The speaker in this talk, a former university professor who argues that education should value creativity as much as literacy.
- TED — The conference where the talk took place, which Robinson describes as a platform for celebrating the human imagination.
- Picasso — Robinson quotes him to make the point that the hard part is not having artistic talent as a child but holding on to it as an adult.
- UNESCO — Robinson cites this organization's forecast to show that the number of graduates worldwide will rise sharply over the next 30 years.
- Epiphany — The book Robinson was writing at the time, which uses interviews to explore how people discover their talents.
- Gillian Lynne — Her school once suspected she had a learning disability. She went on to become a choreographer and worked on the creation of Cats and Phantom of the Opera.
- Royal Ballet School — Gillian Lynne later auditioned for this dance school and graduated from it.
- 学历膨胀 — Robinson's term for the rising academic qualifications required for the same kinds of jobs.
- 人类生态观 — Robinson's view of education, drawn from an ecological perspective, which emphasizes recognizing the richness of human talent rather than developing just one kind.