Justice: What's The Right Thing To Do? Episode 01 "THE MORAL SIDE OF MURDER"
Harvard University54:562009-09-04English
Chapters
This class on justice uses trolley problems, medical dilemmas, and a real shipwreck case to test an intuition: saving more people matters, but numbers alone cannot explain why we accept some sacrifices and reject others.
Overview
Justice: What's The Right Thing To Do? Episode…
- The instructor compares votes on diverting a trolley and pushing someone off a bridge, then asks why students judge the two cases differently when both involve sacrificing one person to save five.
- The contrast between allocating emergency care and transplanting organs brings out two grounds for moral judgment: the consequences of an action and whether the action itself violates a duty or a right.
- The instructor introduces the course readings and public controversies, explaining how philosophy unsettles familiar beliefs and why the difficulty of settling a debate is no reason to stop reasoning about it.
- The class reviews how to test judgments about particular cases against general principles and vice versa, then introduces Bentham’s argument for maximizing utility.
- The instructor recounts the wreck of the Mignonette and the killing of Richard Parker, asking students to set the law aside for now and decide as jurors whether the need to survive provides a moral defense.
- Students compare freely offered consent, consent given under pressure, and a lottery everyone agrees to in advance. They also discuss whether someone can back out once the result is known.
- The instructor tests objections by increasing the number of lives saved and considering the benefit to the men’s families, then leaves three questions about the source of rights, what procedures can justify, and the role of consent.
Key points
- Most students are willing to divert a runaway trolley, trading one death for five lives saved, but are unwilling to push a bystander off a bridge to achieve the same result.
- Most students agree that an emergency doctor should treat five injured people first, but almost no one favors sacrificing a healthy person to save five transplant patients.
- Consequentialism judges right and wrong by the results of an action. Reasoning based on absolute duties holds that some duties and rights do not cease to apply just because the outcome would be better.
- The class’s method is to articulate the principle behind a judgment about a particular case, test it against a new case, and revise either the principle or the original judgment if necessary.
- Bentham understands utility as the net balance of pleasure over pain and argues that both individual actions and public legislation should increase overall happiness as much as possible.
- In the shipwreck case, the defendants argue that what they did was necessary for survival. Even with legal responsibility set aside, most students still find their conduct morally unacceptable.
- When a lottery everyone has agreed to or the uncoerced consent of the person involved is added to the scenario, more students are willing to consider whether the sacrifice is acceptable, though some still believe that killing an innocent person is wrong no matter what.
Chapter notes
Two Trolley Problems
- In the first dilemma, you are driving a trolley hurtling toward five workers at 60 miles per hour. The brakes have failed, and if you go straight, you will certainly hit and kill them. The steering wheel still works, but there is one worker on the side track to the right. Diverting the trolley would sacrifice him and save the five.
- The vast majority of students choose to divert the trolley, reasoning that if only one person has to die, five should not lose their lives. One student who chooses to go straight worries that the same reasoning could be used to justify genocide and totalitarianism.
- In the second dilemma, instead of being the driver, you are a bystander on a bridge. Pushing the man next to you off the bridge to stop the trolley would also sacrifice one person and save five. Most people are unwilling to push him. The instructor asks why the principle almost everyone accepted in the first case no longer seems to apply.
- One student argues that pushing the man draws a bystander who had nothing to do with the accident into it, whereas the driver and the workers on both tracks are already caught up in the danger. The instructor asks how the worker on the side track differs from the man on the bridge, given that neither chose to sacrifice himself.
- Another student argues that diverting the trolley is an emergency decision made after it has already gone out of control, whereas pushing someone with your own hands amounts to killing him directly. Those who disagree point out that turning the steering wheel, just like pushing the man, is a deliberate choice about who dies.
- The instructor asks Andrew if his judgment would change if, instead of pushing the man himself, he could just turn a steering wheel to open a trapdoor beneath the man’s feet. Andrew still thinks this would be more objectionable than diverting the trolley and points out that in the first case you are already involved, whereas in the second you are only a bystander.
Medical Dilemmas and Two Ways of Reasoning
- Six people injured in a trolley accident are brought to the emergency room: five have moderate injuries and one is severely injured. The doctor can save only one group, and the other will die without timely treatment. Only a handful of people choose to save the severely injured patient. The instructor guesses that most people choose to save the five because they are still weighing one life against five.
- A transplant surgeon has five dying patients who need a heart, a lung, a kidney, a liver, and a pancreas, respectively, but there are no donors. Taking those five organs from a healthy person in the next room for a checkup would save the five patients, but the healthy person would die.
- One audience member suggests waiting until the first of the five patients dies and using that patient’s four healthy organs to save the other four. The instructor acknowledges the idea but points out that it sidesteps the philosophical problem under discussion.
- Consequentialist moral reasoning judges right and wrong by the results of an action: even if one person has to die, five people surviving is still the better outcome.
- Some people are unwilling either to push someone off a bridge or to take organs from an innocent person because they believe killing an innocent person is wrong in itself, even if it saves five. Absolutist moral reasoning thus bases moral judgment on requirements, duties, and rights that do not depend on the consequences.
- The most influential example of consequentialism is utilitarianism, founded by the 18th-century British political philosopher Jeremy Bentham. The most important philosopher of absolutist moral reasoning is Immanuel Kant, from 18th-century Germany. The course will go on to compare and assess these two approaches and consider others as well.
Why Philosophy Is Unsettling
- The course will read works by Aristotle, John Locke, Immanuel Kant, John Stuart Mill, and others while debating real controversies such as equality and inequality, affirmative action, free speech and hate speech, same-sex marriage, and military conscription. Putting classic texts alongside these controversies is not just a way to bring abstract readings to life. It also lets each shed light on the other and helps reveal exactly which questions in everyday and political life depend on philosophical judgments.
- What makes the course difficult is precisely that it teaches us things we already know: it takes judgments we take for granted out of familiar, unquestioned settings and makes them seem strange. The opening hypotheticals, both entertaining and serious, work in the same way as philosophical writings: not by supplying new information, but by getting us to see things differently.
- The personal risk of philosophy is that once familiar things become strange, you can never fully return to your old way of seeing them. Self-knowledge is like losing your innocence: once you know, you cannot go back to not knowing. Moral and political philosophy is both difficult and compelling because you do not know where the inquiry will lead, but you know it concerns you personally.
- Political philosophy does not guarantee that people will become more responsible citizens or better at taking part in public affairs. It distances people from conventions, established assumptions, and deeply held beliefs, so it might make them worse citizens, at least before it makes them better ones. In Gorgias, Callicles urges Socrates to give up arguing and learn the skills needed for practical life. He has a point, since that distance can indeed make people less able to act.
- Skepticism is a way out: if generations of philosophers have failed to resolve these questions, how could a single semester do so? Perhaps everyone has their own principles and there is simply no way to reason about them. The instructor replies that the recurrence of these debates shows that however hard the questions are to settle, they cannot be avoided, because every day our actions give some answer to them.
- Immanuel Kant compares skepticism to a resting place for reason. It lets us look back at how we fell into dogmatism, but it is not a place to stay, because settling into doubt cannot quiet reason’s impulse to keep asking questions. The course aims to awaken that restless questioning and see where it leads.
From Moral Intuitions to Utilitarianism
- Marcus thinks that in the desperate situation of going 19 days without food, someone had to be sacrificed so the others could live.
- Using the trolley problems and the healthy patient who might be sacrificed for organ transplants, the class starts with judgments about specific cases and tries to spell out the reasons or principles behind them. When a new case comes up, students use the principle to test their judgment and their judgment to revise the principle, trying to bring the two into agreement.
- Consequentialism judges the morality of an action by its results. Others think the nature of the action itself also carries moral weight. Some actions are still wrong even if they save five lives at the cost of one.
- Utilitarianism is one of the most influential consequentialist theories. Jeremy Bentham, an 18th-century British political philosopher, was the first to set it out clearly and systematically. His central claim is that the right and just thing to do is to maximize utility.
- Bentham understands utility as the amount by which pleasure outweighs pain and happiness outweighs suffering. Starting from the observation that people seek pleasure and dislike pain, he argues that maximizing overall happiness should be the goal of both individual action and public legislation.
- Bentham’s utilitarianism is often summed up as “the greatest good for the greatest number.” To test that principle, the class turns to a real 19th-century English case widely discussed in law schools, the Queen versus Dudley and Stephens, and asks students to imagine they are jurors and reach a verdict after hearing the facts.
The Shipwreck Case and the Defense of Necessity
- The Mignonette was sunk by a wave in the South Atlantic, about 1,300 miles from the cape. Captain Dudley, the first mate, crew member Brooks, and 17-year-old cabin boy Richard Parker escaped in a lifeboat. Parker was an orphan, and this was his first voyage. The boat carried only two tins of pickled turnips and no fresh water.
- The four ate nothing for the first three days, opened a tin of turnips on the fourth day, and caught a sea turtle on the fifth. The turtle and the other tin of turnips kept them going for a few more days, after which they went eight days without food or water. Parker drank seawater against advice and became so ill he was close to death. On day 19, Dudley proposed drawing lots to decide who would be sacrificed to save the other three, but Brooks refused.
- In the end they did not draw lots. The next day, with no ship in sight, Dudley killed Parker. Though Brooks had opposed drawing lots, he joined the other two in subsisting on Parker’s body. On day 24, a German ship rescued the three.
- The three were arrested after being brought back to Falmouth, England. Brooks became a witness for the prosecution, and Dudley and Stephens went on trial. They did not dispute the facts and defended themselves solely on the grounds that it was necessary for survival, arguing that it was better for one to die than for four to die. The prosecution insisted that “murder is murder.” The instructor asks students to act as jurors, put the law aside for the moment, and decide only whether what they did was morally acceptable.
- A fairly clear majority thinks the two men acted immorally. One student who defends them also thinks their actions deserve moral condemnation, but distinguishes moral condemnation from legal responsibility and argues that necessity, if extreme enough, can excuse them from criminal liability.
- Marcus thinks someone had to be sacrificed in such a desperate situation and that the survivors might go on to benefit society. The instructor asks what if they went on to become assassins. Another student who voted guilty suggests that prolonged starvation might impair people’s ability to judge as they normally would. That might offer a defense, but it does not mean the act was morally right.
What Consent and a Lottery Can Change
- Kathleen asks whether Dudley and Stephens could avoid being accused of murder if they got Richard Parker’s consent beforehand. But when she imagines Parker nodding while half-conscious, she still thinks what they did would be morally indefensible.
- One student thinks there would be reason to believe Parker was deciding freely only if he offered to sacrifice himself. If the others brought it up, he might agree under pressure, given that it was three against one.
- Those who object point out that no one knew when help would come, so Parker might have died for nothing. By that logic, the crew might even keep picking off the weakest person one by one until they were rescued. Other students think eating another person is wrong in itself, even if they wait for someone to die naturally.
- More students find the act morally acceptable once the hypothetical includes a lottery everyone agrees to in advance. Matt thinks the problem with the original case is that the others took it upon themselves to decide that their lives mattered more than Parker’s. If everyone agrees to a lottery, each person is willing to take the risk of being sacrificed for the others.
- Another student stresses that no one consulted Parker in the original case. He did not even know the others were discussing whether he should live or die. With a lottery, everyone knows in advance that they might be picked. Asked whether Parker could back out after being picked, the student compares agreeing in advance to a verbal contract: if you would have accepted the result had someone else been picked, you cannot back out just because it was you.
- The instructor sums up by noting that about 20 percent of students find the original case morally acceptable. Others think the key issue is the lack of consent, whether that means agreeing in advance to a fair lottery or Parker himself consenting just before he dies. Once consent is added, more people are willing to consider whether the sacrifice is justified.
The Limits of Rights, Procedure, and Consent
- The instructor asks why killing Parker might still be wrong even if there was a lottery, everyone agreed in advance, or Parker personally consented at the last moment. One student thinks that having the person who draws the losing lot end their own life might avoid murder, but would still involve some coercion. To her, the fact that Dudley wrote only “we were having breakfast” in his diary also suggests a complete lack of remorse and disregard for other people’s lives.
- Following Bentham’s reasoning, it is not enough to count three lives against one. Parker had no family depending on him, whereas the other three had wives, children, or other family members in England, whose well-being would also count in the calculation of total utility. When the instructor raises the number of lives saved to 30, 300, and even 3,000 in wartime, Mike still insists that murder is murder and acknowledges that his position conflicts with Bentham’s standard.
- The instructor sums up: those defending the men appeal to necessity in a desperate situation, the number of people saved, and the effects on their families. Adding up everyone’s happiness and suffering might lead to the conclusion that the men did the right thing.
- The first objection holds that murder is always wrong, even if it increases society’s overall happiness. The first question is whether that absolute prohibition comes from basic rights that even the cabin boy has. If so, and if those rights are not based on overall welfare, utility, or happiness, where do they come from?
- Matt believes a fair lottery changes the judgment: it treats everyone equally, even if one person may still end up being sacrificed for the common good. The second question is why agreeing to take part in a procedure, even a fair one, should be enough to make any outcome it produces legitimate.
- Kathleen’s third question is what moral role consent actually plays. Some people think that if Parker had freely agreed without coercion, taking his life to save the others would have been acceptable. Why can consent make an otherwise immoral act permissible?
What it answers
- Why are some people willing to divert the trolley but not to push the man off the bridge?
- Some think the man on the bridge had nothing to do with the accident and that drawing him into it is different from redirecting a danger that already exists. Others think both actions actively decide who will die, so that distinction is not enough.
- What does Bentham mean by utility?
- Utility is the net balance of pleasure over pain, or happiness over suffering. Individual actions and public policies should be judged by whether they maximize overall happiness.
- How did the defendants in the shipwreck case defend themselves, and how did the class judge their actions?
- Dudley and Stephens did not deny the facts, but argued that in a desperate situation they sacrificed one person so three could live. The class set legal responsibility aside, and most students still thought what they did was morally wrong.
- Why did a lottery change some students’ minds?
- Those in favor think that if everyone agrees in advance and takes the same risk, it is no longer a case of a few people deciding on their own that their lives are worth more than someone else’s. But the class still asks whether agreeing to a fair procedure is enough to legitimize any outcome it produces.
- If philosophical debates have gone unresolved for so long, why keep having them?
- The instructor thinks that however hard these questions are to resolve once and for all, they cannot be avoided, because people give some answer to them through their actions every day.
Quotes
At the end of the day, better that five should live even if one must die.
Philosophy estranges us from the familiar, not by supplying new information, but by inviting and provoking a new way of seeing.
And the reason they're unavoidable, the reason they're inescapable, is that we live some answer to these questions every day.
Why does an act of consent make such a moral difference that an act that would be wrong, taking a life without consent, is morally permissible with consent?
Mentioned
- Jeremy Bentham — The 18th-century British political philosopher introduced in class who systematically set out utilitarianism, with the maximization of utility at its core.
- Immanuel Kant — The class uses him to represent moral reasoning that emphasizes absolute duties and rights, and quotes his remarks on skepticism.
- John Stuart Mill — The instructor says that in the next class, students will read this utilitarian philosopher’s work alongside Bentham’s.
- Socrates — The instructor uses his dialogue with Callicles to show that philosophical reflection can be at odds with active participation in practical life.
- Callicles — In Gorgias, he urges Socrates not to get caught up in philosophical arguments but to learn the skills needed in practical life.
- Dudley — The captain of the Mignonette, who proposed drawing lots, later killed Richard Parker without a lottery, and argued that it was necessary for survival.
- Stephens — The man who stood trial with Dudley and also argued that their actions were necessary.
- Richard Parker — The 17-year-old cabin boy killed in the shipwreck case, who had no part in the discussion that decided his fate.
- Mignonette — The yacht that sank in the South Atlantic, from which four crew members escaped in a lifeboat.
- 后果主义 — A way of reasoning that judges the morality of an action by its results.
- 功利主义 — A consequentialist theory introduced in class that calls for taking into account the happiness and suffering of everyone affected and maximizing overall utility.