Inside the Mind of a Master Procrastinator | Tim Urban | TED

TED14:032016-04-06English

In this TED talk, Tim Urban points out that what we should watch out for most isn't the last-minute scramble, but the important things in life that have no deadline and that we might therefore never start.

Overview

Inside the Mind of a Master Procrastinator

Key points

  • Urban originally planned to write his 90-page senior thesis in stages over a year, but with just 3 days left before it was due, he hadn't written a word. He ended up pulling two all-nighters in a row to finish it, and the thesis was terrible.
  • The Instant Gratification Monkey cares only about whether something is easy and fun right now, while the Rational Decision-Maker considers the future and the big picture. They aren't always at odds: a well-timed break can be both easy and beneficial.
  • In what Urban calls the Dark Playground, people have fun when they should be getting work done, but guilt, anxiety, and fear keep them from really enjoying it.
  • When a deadline approaches or consequences like public embarrassment or a career setback are about to become real, the Panic Monster wakes up, scares the Monkey away, and lets the Rational Decision-Maker take charge again.
  • Things like starting a business, spending time with family, exercising, and dealing with close relationships often have no clear deadline. If last-minute panic is the only thing that gets you moving, you may keep putting these things off, leading to lasting unhappiness and regret.
  • Urban uses a chart covering 90 years, with each square representing one week, to remind the audience that even if they're good at getting things done on time, they should look at which important things without deadlines they keep putting off.

Chapter notes

From a senior thesis to the Instant Gratification Monkey

  • Tim Urban majored in government in college and had to write a lot of papers. Each time, he meant to do some work in the first week and put in more effort later, but he always left it until the end. For his 90-page senior thesis, which was supposed to take a year, he deliberately made a plan that ramped up in stages: write a little at first, do more in the middle, and go all out at the end.
  • The first few months went by without Urban getting started. He revised his plan, but the middle months went by too, and he still hadn't written a word. With just three days before the deadline, he pulled two all-nighters in a row, wrote all 90 pages in 72 hours, and ran across campus to hand it in right at the deadline.
  • The story about the school calling to praise the thesis as "the best one ever" was just a joke. Urban admits it was terrible. Later, he wrote about procrastination on his blog, Wait But Why, to help non-procrastinators who were puzzled by his behavior understand what actually goes on in a procrastinator's head.
  • Urban introduces a metaphor by comparing his own MRI scan with that of someone known not to procrastinate: both have a Rational Decision-Maker in their brains, but the procrastinator also has an Instant Gratification Monkey.
  • Just as the Rational Decision-Maker decides to get some work done, the Monkey grabs the wheel: first, it reads the whole Wikipedia article about the Nancy Kerrigan and Tonya Harding scandal, then checks whether anything new has appeared in the fridge in the last ten minutes, and finally goes from Richard Feynman talking about magnets to an interview with Justin Bieber's mother on YouTube. Before long, the whole day is gone, with no time left to work.
  • The Instant Gratification Monkey lives only in the present, remembers nothing about the past, knows nothing about the future, and cares only whether things are easy and fun. Urban uses dogs as an example: those priorities work in the animal world. To the Monkey, humans are just another kind of animal that needs to get enough sleep, eat its fill, and reproduce, and that approach might have worked back when people lived in tribes.

The Dark Playground and the Panic Monster

  • The Rational Decision-Maker can imagine the future, see the big picture, and make long-term plans, then use them to decide what to do now. When it's a good time to take a break, it doesn't clash with the Monkey, which just wants something easy and fun. But when long-term goals call for harder, less pleasant work, the Monkey often leads procrastinators into the Dark Playground, where things are easy and fun but the timing is wrong.
  • Goofing off in the Dark Playground isn't really enjoyable: you know it isn't time to take a break yet, so even having fun is full of guilt, fear, anxiety, and self-loathing. What lets procrastinators leave the playground and get to work that is less pleasant but genuinely important is the Panic Monster.
  • The Panic Monster usually sleeps. It wakes up only when a deadline is approaching or something awful might happen, like public embarrassment or a career setback. It's the only thing the Monkey is afraid of.
  • Tim Urban got the invitation from TED about six months in advance. Once he accepted, the Rational Decision-Maker urged him to start preparing right away. The Monkey, though, suggested opening Google Earth, setting the view at about 200 feet above the ground, and scrolling north from the southern tip of India for two and a half hours to learn a little more about the country. That's what he did that day.
  • Six months to prepare became four months, then two, then one. After TED announced the lineup, Urban saw his own face on the website, and the Panic Monster finally woke up. The Monkey got scared and climbed a tree, so the Rational Decision-Maker could finally take the wheel again and get him started on the talk.
  • The same mechanism explains why Urban can go two weeks without writing so much as the first sentence of an article, then suddenly stay up all night and write eight pages. That's how the three characters make up his procrastination system: it isn't pretty, but the work gets done in the end.

Procrastination without deadlines

  • A few years earlier, Tim Urban wrote about procrastination on his blog and received thousands of emails from around the world, including from nurses, people who worked in banking, painters, engineers, and many PhD students. They all said they had the same problem. But while the blog post was lighthearted, the emails were full of frustration about what procrastination was doing to their lives.
  • There are two kinds of procrastination. When there's a deadline, the Panic Monster shows up as it approaches, limiting the effects of procrastination to the short term. Without a deadline, the monster has no reason to wake up. Making art or starting a business doesn't come with a deadline at the outset; you have to put in the work yourself before anything can get off the ground. Visiting family, exercising and looking after your health, working on a relationship, or ending one that isn't right for you often have no deadline either.
  • Procrastination without a deadline can go on indefinitely. It's harder to spot and less talked about than short-term procrastination with a deadline, so people often live quietly with lasting dissatisfaction and regret. Urban realized that his readers weren't suffering because they had to scramble to finish a project. They felt like spectators in their own lives. What frustrated them most wasn't that they hadn't achieved their dreams, but that they hadn't even been able to start pursuing them.
  • Urban concludes that no one is entirely free of procrastination. Even people who handle deadlines well are most likely to find the Instant Gratification Monkey quietly taking over when there isn't one.
  • Urban uses a Life Calendar to remind everyone that if you take a 90-year life and give each week one square, there aren't that many squares to begin with, and a fair number are already gone. He asks the audience to think seriously about what they're actually putting off and to keep an eye on the Instant Gratification Monkey, preferably starting today. Then he jokes that it doesn't have to be today, but it should be soon.

What it answers

Why do we switch to doing something else even when we know we should be working?
In Urban's metaphor, the Rational Decision-Maker focuses on long-term goals, but the Instant Gratification Monkey grabs the wheel and goes for whatever is easy and fun right now.
Why isn't goofing off while procrastinating actually fun?
Because you're doing it when you think you should be getting work done, and guilt and anxiety keep you from really relaxing. Urban calls this the Dark Playground.
Why can procrastinators suddenly work so efficiently at the last minute?
When a deadline or serious consequence is looming, the Panic Monster scares off the Instant Gratification Monkey, letting the Rational Decision-Maker take over again and start the work that's been put off.
Why should we be more concerned about procrastination when there's no deadline?
Without a clear deadline, panic won't come to the rescue, and important things can be put off indefinitely. What's truly frustrating isn't even failing to achieve a dream; it's never getting started on pursuing it.

Quotes

He has no memory of the past, no knowledge of the future, and he only cares about two things: easy and fun.
You know, the frustration was not that they couldn't achieve their dreams; it's that they weren't even able to start chasing them.
Well, maybe not today, but you know, sometime soon.

Mentioned

  • Tim Urban — The speaker in this talk, a writer and blogger who explains procrastination through his own experiences.
  • TED — The organization that invited Urban to give the talk. Its announcement of the speaker lineup was what finally got him to start preparing.
  • Wait But Why — The blog where Urban published his piece on procrastination, which drew thousands of emails from readers around the world.
  • 理性决策者 — The character in the procrastination model who imagines the future, considers the big picture, and makes long-term plans.
  • 即时满足猴 — The character in the procrastination model who represents immediate impulses and only wants to do things that are easy and fun.
  • 黑暗游乐场 — The state of goofing off when you shouldn't be, so that even your leisure time is full of guilt and anxiety.
  • 恐慌怪兽 — The character who represents the panic that sets in when a deadline or serious consequence is approaching, and the only one in the model who can scare off the Instant Gratification Monkey.
  • 人生周历 — A chart that shows a lifetime as a grid, with each square representing one week of a life assumed to last 90 years.